Senate Toys With Kid-Safe Domain
Critics contend that law would limit free speech and be ineffective in protecting kids online.
Gretel Johnston, IDG News Service
WASHINGTON -- The U.S. Senate on Thursday began formal consideration of a bill to create kids.us, a second-level Internet domain that would be designed to give parents some peace of mind about their kids' use of the Web by serving up only material deemed appropriate for children.
The Senate Subcommittee on Science, Technology, and Space held a hearing on a Senate version of a bill that overwhelmingly passed the House earlier this year. Both the Senate and the House versions of the "Dot Kids Implementation and Efficiency Act of 2002" (S. 2537 and H.R. 3833), aim to create a "green light" area under the .us country code that consists of sites with content appropriate for children 13 and under.
Under the Senate bill, kids.us Web sites would offer material deemed "suitable for and not harmful to minors." Lawmakers supporting it say the second-level domain would help make parents more aware of what sites their kids are surfing and in turn prevent kids from viewing pornography and other content harmful to minors on the Web. But civil liberties groups are wary.
Opposition Speaks Out
"We have two main concerns. The first is government should not be involved in content rules; the second is will it really be effective," says Center for Democracy and Technology policy analyst Rob Courtney. "Unless we somehow restrict children to only see things in dot kids, we haven't done a lot."
In a letter dated Thursday to the chairman and ranking member of the subcommittee, Alan Davidson, associate director of CDT, drove home those points, telling the subcommittee congressionally mandated creation of a kids.us domain would set a dangerous precedent for regulation of the domain name space. In addition it would create new concerns about free expression online and would be ineffective in protecting children from inappropriate content, Davidson says.
The creation and maintenance of kids.us under the Senate bill "inappropriately involves the government in making decisions about what material should and should not be available on the Internet," Davidson's letter to Senators Ron Wyden (D-Oregon) and George Allen (R- Virginia).
Expensive and Ineffective?
The Senate bill would require NeuStar, the Washington, D.C., company that has been administering the .us domain since March, to make decisions about what is suitable for minors and not harmful to minors. The National Telecommunications and Information Administration would oversee this effort, determining whether Neustar operates in accordance with the mandates of the bill.
To make kids.us effective for parents, the site must be aggressively maintained and monitored, the CDT says.
The kind of enforcement necessary to make the site safe for children would be expensive and difficult, and that money would be better spent educating children and parents how to be safe when using the Web and about the tools already available to filter inappropriate content, Courtney says.
- Sponsored Resource:Improve your network with the right mix of features, performance and pricing.
- Sponsored Resource:Growing your business requires the right tools. Dell's networking servers can help.
- Sponsored Resource:Thinking about a new Laptop? Lenovo has models to meet everyone's needs.
- Sponsored Resource:Twitter: A how-to guide for using Twitter as a business tool.
- Sponsored Resource:Smartphone security threats are on the rise. Is it time to safegaurd your device?
Full Windows 7 coverage
The Best of PC World
Featured APC Accessories
-
APC Back-UPS ES
Safeguards your equipment from damaging surges and spikes that travel along your utility & data lines.
- APC SurgeArrest Performance Highest level of protection for your professional computers, electronics and connected devices, as well as provides surge protection.
People who read this also read:
Best Prices on Cameras
D3000 SLR Digital Camera Kit w/ 18-55mm LensPrice: $514.95
EOS Rebel T1i Black SLR Digital Camera Kit w/ 18-55mm LensPrice: $669.95
EOS Rebel XSi Black SLR Digital Camera KitPrice: $549.95
D90 Black SLR Digital Camera KitPrice: $1059.00
Lumix DMC-FZ35K Black Digital CameraPrice: $315.00
PowerShot G11 Black Digital CameraPrice: $488.95
- Dell Shopping Center Check out great deals from Dell!
Cameras
Camcorders
Cell Phones
Components
Desktops
HDTV
Home Theatre
GPS
Laptops
Monitors
MP3 Players
Networking &
Printers
Storage









