HP, Lexmark Multifunction Units Do It All

Conventional wisdom says that while multifunction devices do many things, they rarely do any of them well. Lexmark's PrinTrio X75 and Hewlett-Packard's PSC 2210 help debunk that notion by offering high-quality ink jet printing, capable scanning, and a host of other goodies.

The shipping version of Lexmark's unique-looking, $150 PrinTrio X75 delivered good prints at reasonable speeds. Printing text, it averaged 4.8 pages per minute, similar to the 5.0-ppm average of ink jets with comparable specifications that we've tested. Draft-quality text was acceptable; higher-precision settings produced sharp, crisp type.

The X75's photo printing time was quite slow, averaging about 0.5 page per minute (0.9 ppm is average). Images looked good, though slightly washed out. Despite the printer's low price, replacement cartridges aren't cheap, at $29 for black (rated at 410 pages) and $32 for color (275 pages).

A shipping version of HP's PSC 2210 justified its higher ($399) price tag with better overall print quality and more features. Photo print speeds were good, averaging 0.9 ppm. The PSC 2210 printed text at a slower-than-average 4.6 ppm, however, and scanning took longer than with the X75.

The HP offers an impressive set of tools, including multiple-format flash memory card readers, onboard faxing, and controls that often permit you to bypass the PC. Replacement cartridges run $20 for black (450 pages) and $35 for color (400 pages).

Aimed primarily at home users, the X75 has an appealing shelf price. HP's more expensive PSC 2210 targets small-business users, and offers better print quality and more features. Neither unit will disappoint, but if you have the extra cash, go with the HP.

SUMMARY

Great prints, numerous features; well suited to small offices. Street price: $400

SUMMARY

Lexmark PrinTrio X75 Good prints, low price; better suited to home users. Street: $150