Massachusetts Appeals Antitrust Ruling
Update: Virginia also refuses to accept the approved Microsoft case settlement.
Stacy Cowley, IDG News Service
Virginia at the last minute has joined Massachusetts in filing an appeal of U.S. District Court Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly's recent Microsoft antitrust settlement ruling.
Microsoft spokesperson Jim Desler confirmed on Monday that the company has heard from West Virginia, saying it will appeal.
On Friday, Massachusetts state Attorney General Tom Reilly said the state expected to pursue the case alone. The other holdout states have accepted Kollar-Kotelly's remedy and are turning their focus to enforcement.
"After a complete remedies trial, we were disappointed when the district court did little more than accept Microsoft's loophole-filled deal," Reilly said. "Microsoft has been found to have repeatedly violated the antitrust laws of this state and this country. We believe a remedy must send a message that breaking the law will not pay. Otherwise, it sends a dangerous message about what is acceptable behavior."
Even Friday, it was speculated that West Virginia might continue to pursue the case. Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller issued a statement Friday confirming that seven states, including his, and the District of Columbia will not appeal the decision.
West Virginia would make its decision by Monday, he said then. Monday was the deadline for the states to appeal.
Moving Forward
Desler said that the appeals will not affect the company's plans moving forward.
"Regardless of decisions by the states our focus remains on complying fully with the court's judgment," Desler said. "I would not characterize [Microsoft] as being surprised or disappointed."
California, Connecticut, Florida, Iowa, Kansas, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Utah, West Virginia, and the District of Columbia were the parties that declined to sign off on the federal government's initial proposed settlement with Microsoft. By continuing to pursue the case, the states won important concessions that strengthened enforcement provisions, Iowa's Miller said Friday.
Illegal Actions
California Attorney General Bill Lockyer also weighed in Friday, saying that the antitrust case has spotlighted Microsoft's illegal behavior.
"While not completely satisfying, the court decree closed enforcement loopholes, keeps compliance with the remedies squarely before the court and allows us to now turn attention to making sure that Microsoft competes fairly in the marketplace," he said in a prepared statement.
Because Microsoft was judged guilty of antitrust violations, the states are entitled to recoup their expenses for the case, which total $25 million in attorney fees and litigation costs, Miller said. Microsoft will also pay the states an additional $3.6 million to be used for funding enforcement efforts, he said.
Massachusetts' Reilly said he is not worried about continuing the case without the participation of the other states.
"We are prepared to go it alone," he said. "We always expected one way or another this would be resolved at the appellate level, and that's where it's going."
Ashlee Vance and Marc Ferranti of the IDG News Service contributed to this report.
Microsoft Office Home and Student 2007
Perfect Print Solutions
- Great year-end deals

for small business! -
Get 24/7 live remote AT&T Tech Support 360* service along with select Lenovo* PCs (with Intel® Core™ 2 Duo processors) and save up to 200!
-
HP EliteBook* 6930p Notebook with Intel® vPro™ technology and a free HP Basic Docking Station - $641 instant savings!
- *Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others. ©2009 Intel Corporation. Intel, the Intel logo, vPro and Core trademarks of Intel Corporation in the United States and other countries. All rights reserved.
Dell End of Year Deals
-
Ring in the New Year with Huge Deals on Dell Computers
Up to 30% Popular Dell Laptops, up to 25% off Popular Dell Desktops. Sales ends 12/31 5AM EST.
People who read this also read:
Best Prices on TVs
DX-L32-10A 32" LCD TVPrice: $299.99
UN55B8000 55" LED TVPrice: $2478.99
UN55B6000 55" LED TVPrice: $1919.99
- Perfect Printing Solutions Find just the right All-in-One Printer for you from HP. Visit the HP Resource Center.
- Acer Laptop Center Forget the Mouse...check out the next generation multi-gesture touch screen technology from Acer.
- Dell Shopping Center Check out great deals from Dell!
Cameras
Camcorders
Cell Phones
Components
Desktops
HDTV
Home Theater
GPS
Laptops
Monitors
MP3 Players
Networking &
Printers
Storage







