Extra-Suite Virus and Spam Protection

Like a small town in a Dashiell Hammett novel, the Internet can be a dirty and dangerous place. The biggest movers in the PC protection business, Symantec and McAfee, sell software to protect your computer from various online thugs. Now, both companies have updated their suites so that one installation routine delivers better antivirus programs, spam filters, and firewall protection.

The antivirus section of Norton Internet Security 2004 uses red letters to alert you to something that needs immediate attention.
Besides saving you money, the suites give you a single, integrated interface for setting up, controlling, and regularly updating the programs. In addition, both suites offer better parental-control tools than you'll find in the also-available stand-alone packages.

I looked at the components of Symantec's $70 Norton Internet Security 2004 (Norton AntiVirus, Norton Personal Firewall, and Norton AntiSpam) and of McAfee's $70 Internet Security Suite 6 (McAfee VirusScan 8, McAfee Personal Firewall Plus 5, Privacy Service 6, and McAfee SpamKiller Home Edition 5). Neither suite was complete; I assessed a combination of beta and final code in order to evaluate all of the programs.

Stop the Spam

The problem with spam filters is that so much guesswork is involved, and it's so easy to guess wrong. When first installed, both Norton AntiSpam and McAfee SpamKiller 5 overwhelmed me with a barrage of unfiltered junk. Even worse, they generated a great many false positives--legitimate mail that they rejected as spam. If you have to scrutinize all your spam every day in search of good messages, why install a filter?

Separating the wheat from the spam becomes needlessly difficult when McAfee forces you out of your e-mail program.
But both proved quick learners. After I identified incorrect choices, each app took only a few days to reduce false positives to virtually zero.

Norton managed almost as well with reducing the volume of undetected spam, but McAfee never quite got the hang of that. I'm not sure whether it's a slower learner or whether its clumsy design prevented me from properly showing it all of its mistakes.

Whereas Norton AntiSpam integrates well with various versions of Outlook, Outlook Express, and Eudora, McAfee's setup pretty much requires you to launch the SpamKiller program to find false positives and then instruct it on handling them. If you have Outlook Express 6 or Outlook with a MAPI e-mail account, you can teach SpamKiller about missed spam from within your e-mail client, but you have to do it one message at a time.

On the other hand, both vendors' firewall and antivirus products are easy to figure out and use. For instance, each company maintains an online database of legitimate programs, and each firewall consults it to see if a program is legitimate and should be allowed free access to the Internet. This reduces the number of times the firewall will interrupt you to ask permission.

And both companies' antivirus programs have clear and pleasing user interfaces. Norton AntiVirus tells you in big red letters when something requires your attention (for instance, if it has been too long since you last scanned for viruses). McAfee VirusScan 8 pops up information about the latest viruses. Each program touts its protection against adware and spyware programs that alter Windows, spy on you, and place advertisements on your screen.

Get Activated

This year Norton has added product activation to its entire 2004 line. When I installed the suite, an applet checked a database on the company's server to make sure that I was not installing the software onto too many PCs. This particular activation scheme is far from the worst I've seen. But for users who hate this form of antipiracy protection, it's a point against Norton.

Both suites are likely to protect you against Internet dangers. But Norton gets my nod thanks to its easier and better-integrated spam filtering.

McAfee Internet Security Suite 6

Beta software, not rated
Offers good protection, but the spam filter has a clumsy interface.
Price when reviewed: $70
Current prices (if available)

Symantec Norton Internet Security 2004

Beta software, not rated
Best all-in-one Internet protection package has improved spam filter.
Price when reviewed: $70
Current prices (if available)

To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
Shop Tech Products at Amazon