Online chat rooms and bulletin boards populated by file-swapping fans are filled with postings comparing the Recording Industry Association of America to a Mafia-like syndicate. Now, one target of the group's lawsuits against alleged music pirates is asking the judicial system to back that assessment.
A New Jersey woman has filed a lawsuit against the RIAA under anti-racketeering statues, charging the group with using scare tactics to extort money from the individuals it sues.
Scare Tactics Claimed
The RIAA has settled a number of those lawsuits--and therein lies the problem, according to the complaint Scimeca filed in the U.S. District Court for New Jersey.
"Instead of merely providing service of the complaint upon the various defendants, including Ms. Scimeca, the Plaintiffs have opted to include a letter discussing and prompting settlement of the copyright infringement action," the complaint states. "This scare tactic has caused a vast amount of settlements from individuals who feared fighting such a large institution and feel victim to these actions and felt forced to provide funds to settle these actions instead of fighting the institution."
The complaint argues that the RIAA's lawsuit campaign's main intent is to extract financial settlements from those sued. It charges the group with violating Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations laws.
Scimeca's lawyer, Bart Lombardo, says his client will also challenge the legality of suing individuals for online file-sharing through peer-to-peer networks like Kazaa.
"This counterclaim that we're filing is about the tactics used to enforce," he says. "Of course, we'll also be arguing the legality of the downloading, but that's a separate matter."
Other Antipiracy Action
The case is similar to that of a California man, who charges the RIAA is misleading people into admitting their guilt through its Clean Slate program that alleges to offer amnesty to repentant file-swappers.
An RIAA representative did not return a call seeking comment. At an unrelated press conference Thursday, RIAA Director of Antipiracy Brad Buckles said he had not yet seen a copy of the lawsuit and declined comment. He defended the organization's campaign of lawsuits against individual file-swappers.
"We think the lawsuits are being very successful," he said. "I think we've seen some great strides out of that. People are beginning to realize that what at first blush might seem like innocent activity, moving files around on the Internet, is in fact theft of property from artists and companies."