Online Photo Services Shootout

Photo Services: Features Comparison Chart

Photo Service PCW Rating Overall print quality Print pricing
Kodak EasyShare Gallery
Best Buy
80
Very Good
4 by 6: Very Good
5 by 7: Very Good
8 by 10: Good
4 by 6: $0.15
5 by 7: $0.99
8 by 10: $3.99
Bottom line: Kodak's easy-to-use site makes a good range of features available and earned the highest print quality ratings overall.
Snapfish 77
Good
4 by 6: Good
5 by 7: Good
8 by 10: Good
4 by 6: $0.12
5 by 7: $0.79
8 by 10: $2.99
Bottom line: This well-designed site came through with good prints and reasonable prices, plus the option of fast pickup at Walgreens.
Shutterfly 75
Good
4 by 6: Good
5 by 7: Good
8 by 10: Very Good
4 by 6: $0.19
5 by 7: $0.99
8 by 10: $3.99
Bottom line: The interface is a joy to use and print quality is solid, but high prices and lack of pickup options hurt the final rating.
Yahoo Photos 74
Good
4 by 6: Fair
5 by 7: Fair
8 by 10: Very Good
4 by 6: $0.15
5 by 7: $0.59
8 by 10: $1.99
Bottom line: This service's sparsely designed site offers numerous editing features and good prices, but print quality was inconsistent.
Wal-Mart Photo Center 69
Fair
4 by 6: Fair
5 by 7: Fair
8 by 10: Good
4 by 6: $0.12
5 by 7: $0.58
8 by 10: $1.96
Bottom line: Low prices and in-store pickup options don't make up for this service's lackluster site tools and dismal print quality.
Canon Pixma iP6600D Not
applicable 1
4 by 6: Very Good
5 by 7: Very Good
8 by 10: Good
4 by 6: $0.65 2
5 by 7: $1.05 2
8 by 10: $1.12 2
Bottom line: This $200 photo printer matched the print quality of the top-rated Kodak EasyShare Gallery service--without the wait.
1 This printer's PCW rating was derived from noncomparable test measures; see "Top 5 Photo Printers" chart.
2Vendor's estimate of cost per print.
Shop ▾
arrow up Amazon Shop buttons are programmatically attached to all reviews, regardless of products' final review scores. Our parent company, IDG, receives advertisement revenue for shopping activity generated by the links. Because the buttons are attached programmatically, they should not be interpreted as editorial endorsements.

Subscribe to the Daily Downloads Newsletter

Comments