At 4.5 pounds, the new MacBook is half a pound lighter than the old version. With its new complement of previously-Pro-only features and its lighter weight, people who have been considering the MacBook Air will probably want to give that purchase some more consideration. The new MacBook isn't close to the three-pound Air on weight, but it's noticeably lighter than its predecessor and it's cheaper and faster than the Air. As a MacBook Air user, I will have to seriously consider switching back to the MacBook now that it's gained these new features and lightened its load by half a pound.
The MacBook Pro, on the other hand, is two-tenths of a pound heavier than its predecessor. In practice you probably wouldn't notice the difference, but the Pro definitely didn't go on the same diet as the MacBook.
The new MacBook Pro has two separate graphics subsystems inside of it. One, the NVIDIA GeForce 9400M, is the same one found in the new MacBook and MacBook Air models. It's less powerful--and uses less power. The other, the NVIDIA GeForce 9600M GT, is a much faster, higher-performance graphics processor. To choose which one you use, you must go to the Energy Saver preference pane, fresh with its new icon. (The Energy Saver icon used to be an incandescent light bulb; Apple has replaced it with a compact fluorescent as a part of its quest to reduce the energy consumption of its icons.)
Within the Energy Saver preference pane, you can choose between "Better battery life" (the 9400M) and "Higher performance" (the 9600M GT) for graphics. However, this isn't a switch you can do on the fly--nor can you set the system to use one when you're on battery power and the other when you're attached to an outlet. In fact, to switch between the two cards requires you to log out of your user account and log back in.
Yes, it's true--these new MacBooks work with your iPhone headphones. If you click the button on your iPhone headphones, iTunes pauses. Click again, and the music resumes. A double-click advances one track, and a triple-click moves back a track--just like on the iPhone. What's more, the headphones' built-in microphone appears as the input device "Microphone port" in the Sound preference pane.
Both models use the same keyboard, the one that debuted on the MacBook and then made its way to the MacBook Air. If you love it--or hate it--you probably already know. As for me, I find the feel identical to other recent Apple laptops, even though the look is a bit different.
Migration and Target Disk Mode
The new MacBook, like the MacBook Air, lacks a FireWire port entirely. What this means is that the old laptop data-transfer standby known as Target Disk Mode--enabled by holding down the T key upon startup, allowing your laptop's hard drive to appear as an external hard drive when plugged in to another computer--is gone. And there's no USB equivalent of Target Disk Mode. What this means is, if you're using Apple's Migration Assistant to move your data to the new MacBook, you'll have to transfer your data over the network from your other computer. (The fastest solution: attach via an Ethernet cable and do it direct at full speed.)
Look out below!
When the original MacBook came out, one of my favorite features was the easy access it provided to its hard drive and RAM, both of which lurked behind a few screws under the laptop's battery bay. Sadly, the MacBook Pro remained extremely hard to upgrade--until now. These are the most upgradeable Apple laptops yet.
Both models are identical in this respect. On the bottom side of the computer there's a switch you flip up, which releases a metal door.
Lift it off, and beneath you'll find a battery and a hard drive.
To remove the battery, just pull up on the plastic tab attached to it and it'll lift right out. To remove the hard drive, you'll need a small Phillips screwdriver in order to remove a single screw from a small plastic locking mechanism that sits between the main laptop case and the drive. Then lift the drive out and disconnect it from the drive cable.
Reaching the RAM's a bit more involved: you need to use that same screwdriver to remove eight screws at the top and bottom of the undershell of the MacBook case. The entire bottom shell lifts off, and you'll see two RAM slots right above the battery bay, dead center. (The MacBooks both have two SO-DIMM slots for a maximum RAM total of 4GB.)
An important note about the battery: it no longer comes with its own battery-level light. (Which would be tricky, since it's hidden behind the removable door.) Instead, on the left side of both models there's a small button that you press to see the capacity of the currently inserted battery. You'll get a more detailed look than in previous models, too: eight tiny battery lights make up the battery-status display.
It's worth noting that while the old MacBook line (still kicking around as a $999 low-end MacBook) let you choose between white and black models, with these new MacBooks you can have any color you like, so long as it's silver. However, in line with the latest iMac models, it's a definite silver-and-black look, thanks to the keyboard and the solid black glass face of the display. Even the display's hinge is black, as opposed to the gray found in the Macbook Air.
Out of the box
Not five minutes out of the box and already a software update.
Apple crows about the reduced waste in the packaging of these products, and it's true. They follow the MacBook Air approach: it's a tiny box with not a whole lot in it. (Not even any video adapters.) But it's definitely less wasteful packaging.
Once I got the computers out of the box, I was immediately slapped with a Software Update notice. Between the installation of software on the systems at the factory in China and their arrival in the United States, Apple's software engineers evidently fixed some bugs. I was immediately prompted with an alert to update to Version 1.2 of the MacBook, MacBook Pro Software Update for "precision aluminum unibody enclosure MacBook and MacBook Pro notebook computers." Whew!
After a few hours with these systems, I have to say that I like them a lot. The new trackpad takes some getting used to, but I think most users will like it. Lovers of matte displays will be angry, though that anger might be mitigated by third-party anti-glare overlays. And the displays themselves are bright and beautiful, which is a good thing. The new graphics performance of these systems--especially the MacBook, which previously used Intel's integrated graphics--should be good, though we'll have to wait for Macworld Lab to weigh in to know for sure.
Thus ends my rapid-fire hands-on look of the MacBook and MacBook Pro. Stay tuned later this week for Macworld Lab's tests of these systems, followed by complete reviews. And when the new MacBook Air arrives in November, we'll take that one for a spin as well.
Jason Snell is Macworld's editorial director. You can follow him on Twitter. Jason thanks the good folks on Twitter for suggesting so many of the questions he answered in this story.
This story, "First Look: MacBook and MacBook Pro" was originally published by Macworld.