No-Commit iPhone Priced To Fail

If you believe a published report, AT&T is about to (finally) make good on its promise to offer a "pay-as-you-go" iPhone, sold without the usual requirement for a two-year service contact. Commitment phobia, however, comes at a high price.

Here are details of the rumored deal, supposed to become effective next week:

Drop by the AT&T store, plunk down $599 or $699 and you get an 8 or 16GB iPhone, sans the usual two-year service contract. This "no-commit" pricing is only available to existing AT&T wireless customers and activation is not required at time-of-sale.

Under AT&T's current pricing, basic iPhone voice and data costs $69.95-a-month, with text messaging an additional $5-$20 monthly, depending on how many messages you expect to send.

Is the no-commit iPhone a good deal?

Let's say you buy an 8GB iPhone at the subsidized price of $199 with the required two-year service plan. If you cancel service on day 31 of the contract, the early termination fee is "up to $175" according to AT&T's Web site.
The $199 phone plus $175 for early termination adds up to $374, which is $225 less than the $599 "a la carte" price for the same iPhone.

Unless AT&T offers a discount on service if you buy an iPhone at the non-subsidized price, I cannot imagine why any sensible person would pay $599 or $699 for an iPhone if it could be avoided.

Some customers, however, might not be able to get a discounted price. If you have not owned your current AT&T phone long enough to get a discounted upgrade, the no-commitment price might be the best deal you're offered.

For example, a phone that is stolen shortly after it was purchased at the discounted price might only be replaceable at the no-commit price. (AT&T does not offer iPhone insurance).

One way to avoid paying the no-commit price might be to pay the $175 early termination fee and see if AT&T will then let you then sign up as a "new" customer. Otherwise, the crime victim might have to get a new account using someone else's name, credit, and Social Security number to avoid the no-commit pricing.

Maybe AT&T really doesn't intend to sell (m)any at those prices. Maybe no-commit pricing is just a way to impress their regular customers with how much buying a phone with a two-year commitment "saves" them. Yes, that's very impressive.

David Coursey is an iPhone user who likes avoiding long-term service contracts. Contact him at

Shop ▾
arrow up Amazon Shop buttons are programmatically attached to all reviews, regardless of products' final review scores. Our parent company, IDG, receives advertisement revenue for shopping activity generated by the links. Because the buttons are attached programmatically, they should not be interpreted as editorial endorsements.

Subscribe to the Best of PCWorld Newsletter