- Recommend:
- 0 Comments
Net Phones: Dialing Without Dollars
Talk may be cheap with free and low-cost Internet phones, but can you count on getting through? Learn the highlights and hazards from our test of ten Net phone services.
What You'll Need
To get started using an Internet phone service, all you need is a sound card with a microphone and speakers, a 56-kbps modem, an Internet connection (AOL is okay), and a browser. To increase your chances of making the service work right, though, you need to do a few things.
First, make sure your sound card is full-duplex, and upgrade if necessary. Most old sound cards are half-duplex--you'll know you have an older card if only one person can talk at a time, as with a two-way radio. If you're running at half-duplex, you might be able to fix the problem with a new driver. Check your sound card maker's Web site for an update. In my tests, I used both Creative Labs Sound Blaster Live and AWE full-duplex sound cards with no problem.
Next, you should consider buying a sturdy headset. This device will help block external noise, making it easier to hear the caller. And in most cases a headset is superior in quality to the sticklike microphone that sometimes accompanies sound cards. Even poor connections sound better over a good headset.
Finding a comfortable, technically solid headset involves trial and error. One of my favorites is Andrea's $40 NC-72 PC monaural. It's lightweight, and people said my voice sounded terrific. For comfort and quality, Telex's $90 H-551, a stereo USB headset, was another winner. Riparius's $25 telephone-like handset (sold by ZeroPlus) was hard to hold, and Labtec's $50 LVA-8550 was the worst of the bunch, with poor sound reception from the earphones and substandard audio transmission.
If you don't like headsets, try Net2Phone's $55 Yap Phone, a handheld device that looks like a phone and connects to your PC. Calling someone who owns a Yap Phone is free. If the person you're calling doesn't have one, calls cost a penny a minute in the United States and 3.9 cents or more a minute for overseas calls. But the Yap Phone performed no better than Net phones used with a headset, and working with it wasn't any easier.
Another Net2Phone product, the Yap Jack--which charges the same fees as the Yap Phone--doesn't require either party to have a PC, but the caller does need an Internet service provider. Attach a regular phone to the $160 Yap Jack, connect the Yap Jack to the wall jack, and start making calls. The Yap Jack was handy, but setup was arduous. It's also mighty expensive. Net2Phone offers a calling card, too. Its rates are about the same as those of online services, and it doesn't require you to make calls from your PC.
Net Connection Matters
If you have a dial-up connection, you must use a 56-kbps modem. Anything slower, and you'll experience dreadful voice quality--static, dropped words, and echoes. That said, even with a 56-kbps modem, I frequently had to play the CB radio game of saying "over" to signal I was finished speaking.
Dick Norton, a frequent Internet phone user in Burbank, California, uses Dialpad with his 56-kbps modem. He reports that his calls "typically last 30 to 40 minutes and are good quality on an amazingly consistent basis."
If you want your Internet phone to work like a regular phone--and you plan to use it on a regular basis--get a high-speed DSL or cable modem connection. Voice quality was substantially better (but still imperfect) in all my tests using cable or DSL.
I'm not the only one with a preference for a high-speed connection. "My uncle in Texas called me [in Canada] on his dial-up connection, and it was worse than a ham radio communication to Mars," says Shawn R. Ahmed, a student in Bedford, Nova Scotia. Yet when I used DSL to call Ahmed on Deltathree's PC-to-phone product (and again when he used his cable modem to call me), we understood each other easily.
As broadband ramps up, the technology behind Internet phone services will undoubtedly improve, but don't say adios to Ma Bell just yet. For the time being, most of us will use Internet calls only for shooting the breeze with friends and relatives. I predict, however, that in three years you'll probably make at least half your calls via Internet phones. But until Web-based telephony becomes as easy to use as regular phone service and offers the latter's crystal-clear quality, few of us will switch to it completely for our business calls.
Extra Gear
|
|
|
|
|
Would you recommend this story? YES NO
- Recommend:
- 0 Comments
-
ThinkPad Edge E420 Lenovo Style in an Affordable Package
Buy now direct from Lenovo -
ThinkPad X220 Fast and light, with great input ergonomics and battery life, this powerhouse ultraportable is best-of-breed.
Buy now direct from Lenovo -
ThinkPad X120e One of the best netbooks ever, X120e has the best netbook keyboard ever--nothing else comes close
Buy now direct from Lenovo
- 12 Criteria for Selecting the Best ERP System Replacement An ERP system is your information backbone and reaches into all areas of your business and value chain. Replacing it can open unlimited business opportunities. This white paper explains the 12 criteria that allow you to identify and select the solution that will meet these expectations.
- Leveraging Social Computing Technologies for ERP Applications This white paper details how Web 2.0 technologies support business strategies by improving efficiency, productivity, and collaboration.

















