Brother HL-3070cw Color LED Printer Has Wi-Fi but Comes With Trade-Offs

Editor's note: PCWorld has updated the speed results for this product. After identifying a conflict with a test file that affected this and a few other, unrelated printers, PCWorld Labs revised the file and retested the product. Its speed results for plain text improved from 8.8 ppm to 10 ppm.

The Brother HL-3070cw color LED printer gives small offices color printing on the cheap (for $350 as of March 1, 2010), and it has Wi-Fi, too. As is the case with many bargains, however, it makes some compromises, namely in speed and print quality; it also has a few frustrating features.

Unfortunately, the HL-3070cw is a little slow and clumsy at printing. On a PC, text pages printed at a sedate 10 pages per minute (ppm). Color speed ranged from 3.5 ppm at default settings on plain paper to 1.8 ppm printing photos on special paper. On a Mac, the HL-3070cw was a little faster, averaging 9.8 ppm with text and 3.6 ppm with graphics. Text quality was as crisp as you'd expect from any laser. All grayscale and color graphics suffered from a grainy effect, however, and color graphics looked pale. The Dell 2130cn prints better graphics, but its toner costs are exorbitant.

The HL-3070cw's feature set is basic (not surprising, given the price). The single, 250-sheet input tray is not upgradable, and the manual-feed slot for thicker media is a hassle because you have to feed the sheets piece by piece. A rear panel folds down to create a straight paper path. On the control panel, the tiny, one-line LCD is unreadable from most angles other than near dead-on. The navigation buttons confused us initially because the cancel and enter buttons are where we expect the left and right arrow buttons to be. The Xerox Phaser 6140/N has better design and features for the price.

Offsetting the HL-3070cw's low purchase price are its higher toner costs. The printer ships with starter-size, 1000-page cartridges for each color and a set of separate drums, also for each color. The replacement black cartridge costs $75 and lasts 2200 pages, or 3.4 cents per page. Each color is priced at $70 and lasts 1400 pages, or 5 cents per color per page. A page with all four colors would cost 18.4 cents. When you hit 15,000 pages of output, you'll need to replace the drums; a new set costs $150, or 1 cent per page. Inserting and removing the toner supplies is very easy, but they don't lock into their bays, which is a bit disconcerting.

Keep your expectations for the Brother HL-3070cw as modest as its price. It can add basic color elements to your documents, but smooth-looking photos are a stretch.