Brother HL-3070cw Color LED Printer Has Wi-Fi but Comes With Trade-Offs
At a Glance
Amazon Shop buttons are programmatically attached to all reviews, regardless of products' final review scores. Our parent company, IDG, receives advertisement revenue for shopping activity generated by the links. Because the buttons are attached programmatically, they should not be interpreted as editorial endorsements.
Getting wireless connectivity at this price point is a nice bonus, but the HL-3070cw color printer is fairly slow and sparsely featured.
Editor's note: PCWorld has updated the speed results for this product. After identifying a conflict with a test file that affected this and a few other, unrelated printers, PCWorld Labs revised the file and retested the product. Its speed results for plain text improved from 8.8 ppm to 10 ppm.
The Brother HL-3070cw color LED printer gives small offices color printing on the cheap (for $350 as of March 1, 2010), and it has Wi-Fi, too. As is the case with many bargains, however, it makes some compromises, namely in speed and print quality; it also has a few frustrating features.
Wi-Fi connectivity is still uncommon among color laser and LED printers, so its presence on the HL-3070cw is a nice bonus. The setup involves a lot of steps, though: For us, clicking blindly through the terse and overly technical dialog boxes proved successful but tedious.
Unfortunately, the HL-3070cw is a little slow and clumsy at printing. On a PC, text pages printed at a sedate 10 pages per minute (ppm). Color speed ranged from 3.5 ppm at default settings on plain paper to 1.8 ppm printing photos on special paper. On a Mac, the HL-3070cw was a little faster, averaging 9.8 ppm with text and 3.6 ppm with graphics. Text quality was as crisp as you'd expect from any laser. All grayscale and color graphics suffered from a grainy effect, however, and color graphics looked pale. The Dell 2130cn prints better graphics, but its toner costs are exorbitant.
The HL-3070cw's feature set is basic (not surprising, given the price). The single, 250-sheet input tray is not upgradable, and the manual-feed slot for thicker media is a hassle because you have to feed the sheets piece by piece. A rear panel folds down to create a straight paper path. On the control panel, the tiny, one-line LCD is unreadable from most angles other than near dead-on. The navigation buttons confused us initially because the cancel and enter buttons are where we expect the left and right arrow buttons to be. The Xerox Phaser 6140/N has better design and features for the price.
Offsetting the HL-3070cw's low purchase price are its higher toner costs. The printer ships with starter-size, 1000-page cartridges for each color and a set of separate drums, also for each color. The replacement black cartridge costs $75 and lasts 2200 pages, or 3.4 cents per page. Each color is priced at $70 and lasts 1400 pages, or 5 cents per color per page. A page with all four colors would cost 18.4 cents. When you hit 15,000 pages of output, you'll need to replace the drums; a new set costs $150, or 1 cent per page. Inserting and removing the toner supplies is very easy, but they don't lock into their bays, which is a bit disconcerting.
Keep your expectations for the Brother HL-3070cw as modest as its price. It can add basic color elements to your documents, but smooth-looking photos are a stretch.