Slate Wars: 15 Tablets That Could Rival Apple's iPad

It wasn't the Courier tablet that many attendees hoped Steve Ballmer would pull out of his hat at CES in January, but HP's slate PC (don't call it a tablet!) is shaping up as a strong alternative to the iPad. It doesn't have an official name yet, but some of its specs--including a 8.9-inch multitouch screen, Windows 7, and support for hardware-accelerated Flash video playback--are public knowledge. Running Amazon's Kindle app could be pretty neat on this thing. HP reportedly is also working on a range of tablets, one of which is a miniature Android device intended to compete with the 5-inch Dell Streak.

Update: Engadget has posted what looks like an internal HP presentation that says the Slate will cost $549-$599. Listed specs include an 8.9-inch (1024-by-600-pixel) display, HDMI-output, 32- or 64GB storage, an integrated SDXC card reader and single USB 2.0 port, a SIM card slot, and a 3-megapixel forward-facing camera. If the listing is to be believed, the Slate is powered by a 1.6GHz Z530 Atom processor coupled with 1GB RAM, and you'll also get 802.11b/g (but not wireless-N) Wi-Fi.

OS: Windows 7

Key specs: 8.9-inch multitouch display, processor unknown, Atom processor, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, possible back-mounted camera

Other features: 3D Accelerated Flash (unknown whether this means it has a Broadcom Crystal HD Accelerator or nVidia Ion graphics)

Size and weight: Unknown

Due: Later this year (June is the rumored target month)

Price: $549-$600

The notorious CrunchPad-turned-JooJoo tablet has just started shipping, and--as you can see--the interface has come a long way from where it was when we tested a preproduction model back in December 2009. The $499 slate has a big 12.1-inch capacitive multitouch display and runs Ubuntu Linux with a custom interface. It can play Flash video out of the box, and it will be able to handle high-def Flash once Flash 10.1 arrives. Unfortunately, the JooJoo only uses first-generation Ion graphics, its apps are all Web-based, and the $499 price fetches a machine with only 4GB of storage--albeit on a solid-state drive.

OS: Ubuntu Linux with custom WebKit-based browser interface

Key specs: 12.1-inch capacitive multitouch display (1366 by 768 pixels), 1.6GHz Intel Atom CPU, nVidia Ion graphics, 1GB of RAM, 4GB solid-state drive, 802.11n Wi-Fi, Bluetooth

Other features: Built-in still/video camera, accelerometer, ambient light sensor

Size and weight: 12.8 by 7.8 by 0.7 inches (height by width by maximum thickness); 2.4 pounds

Due: Available now

Price: $499

Dell is working on a "family of tablets," the first of which will be its Android tablet--perhaps under the model name Mini 5 or Streak. This unit's 5-inch multitouch display is more pocket-friendly than the ones on most upcoming tablets, but it's also larger than the displays on most smartphones (yes, the Mini 5 can make calls). It also has a front-facing camera (for video chat), voice recognition, a speedy 1GHz Snapdragon CPU, and various color options. Picture courtesy of Engadget, which recently posted Dell documents suggesting that Amazon apps for books, video, and music could come preinstalled as well. This is definitely a contender to watch.

OS: Android 2.x

Key specs: 5-inch LED-backlit, capacitive multitouch display (800 by 480 pixels), 1GHz Qualcomm Snapdragon CPU, 405MB of DRAM, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, 3G

Other features: 5-megapixel camera with dual LED flash, second front-facing camera (648 by 480 pixels), SIM card and microSD card slots, GPS

Size and weight: About 5.9 by 3.1 by 0.4 inches (height by width by thickness); 8 ounces

Due: Unconfirmed, but expected around June 2010

Price: Unknown

As a laptop, the IdeaPad U1 runs Windows 7 with a 1.3GHz Core 2 Duo SU4100 chip; but pop the screen off, and the machine instantly becomes a multitouch tablet running its own widget-style Linux interface. And get this: Some tasks, such as open Web pages, automatically continue between both modes. The keyboard base can operate independently, the screen includes 3G, and Lenovo rates the unit's battery life at about 8 hours. Sounds great, but the U1's popularity could hinge on its final price and on how responsive its resistive display is to touch. Image credit: Gizmodo.

OS: Lenovo Skylight Linux (tablet mode) and Windows 7 (laptop mode)

Key specs: 11.6-inch LED-backlit resistive multitouch display (1366 by 768 pixels)

Tablet specs: 1GHz Qualcomm Snapdragon CPU, 16GB solid-state drive

Laptop specs: 1.3GHz Intel Core 2 Duo SU4100 CPU, 128GB solid-state drive, HDMI output, 802.11b/g Wi-Fi, 3G

Other features: 1.3-megapixel Webcam, media card reader

Size and weight: 1.6 pounds (tablet only), 3.8 pounds (screen and keyboard base)

Due: June 1

Price: $999 without carrier subsidies

One tablet that might match Apple in user interface innovation is the mysterious Microsoft Courier, a folding dual-screen device that's more of a pen and touch-controlled digital journal/eReader than a media tablet along the lines of the iPad. Despite several leaks and supposed slip-ups, will the Courier make the leap from concept to consumer item? Maybe. Citing an "extremely trusted source," Engadget recently reported that the Courier is on track for the second half of 2010, will use nVidia's Tegra 2 chip, and will run the same OS platform as Microsoft's Zune HD and Windows Mobile 7 Series Phones. Fingers crossed that Redmond achieves something special here. Image credit: Engadget (where you can also watch a video of the Courier's interface in action).

Rumored specs...

OS: Based on the Windows CE 6 kernel (also the basis for Windows Phone 7 smartphones and the Zune HD)

Key specs: Twin multitouch screens capable of pen input, nVidia Tegra 2 processors

Other features: Pen-centric interface with handwriting recognition

Size and weight: Less than 1 inch thick, About 5 by 7 by less than 1 inch (height by width by thickness) when closed; weight will be a little over 1 pound

Due: Second half of 2010

Price: Unknown

Everything about this tablet screams innovation. Designed in India, the Adam uses a special multitouch-enabled 10.1-inch transflective screen from Pixel Qi that switches between sunlight-friendly e-paper and color LCD modes. It also has a 3.2-megapixel, 180-degree-swivel camera; a high-def-video-capable Tegra 2 processor; an HDMI port; 3G; and GPS. It has been previewed running Android 2.1. A cheaper (and thinner) standard screen version will also be available this summer when the Adam launches.

OS: Android 2.x (Ubuntu Linux and Chrome OS versions are expected, too)

Key specs: 10.1-inch PixelQi transflective display with dual modes (e-ink and color LCD) and multitouch (1024 by 600 pixels), nVidia Tegra 2 graphics and dual-core ARM Cortex-A9 CPU, 16GB or 32GB solid-state drive, Wi-Fi, 3G

Other features: 3.2-megapixel, 180-degree-swivel camera; reverse-side trackpad; HDMI output; microSD card slot; accelerometer; ambient light sensor; GPS

Size and weight: 9.4 by 6.2 by 0.5 inches (height by width by thickness); 1.4 pounds

Due: June or July 2010

Price: $327 to $800

If you like the idea of flicking through Web pages or e-books by touch, but you don't want to give up your physical keyboard, a netbook equipped with a swiveling screen could be a good compromise choice. Over the next few months, several new "netvertibles" (hmm, wonder if this means that the Internet's backbone will soon become known as the "netvertebrate"?) will emerge, including the Lenovo IdeaPad S10-3T (available now), Viliv S10 Blade, Asus Eee PC T101MT and the Gigabyte Touch Note T1000P. Each will have a 10.1-inch multitouch display, run Windows 7, and cost around $500 bucks. That's cheaper than standard 12.1-inch convertibles such as the multitouch-capable HP TouchSmart tm2t and Lenovo ThinkPad X201T.

A Windows 7 device with a custom touch interface, an 8.9-inch multitouch screen, netbook-like specs, and Flash support--okay, you have our attention. The ExoPC Slate was scheduled to arrive at the end of March, but ExoPC recently told Engadget that it has postponed the launch to June or July. When the tablet arrives, you can expect improvements such as "better processor, graphics, battery life, thinner design, plus better screen and touch panel" compared to the current official specs listed here.

OS: Windows 7 Premium

Key specs: 8.9-inch LED-backlit " High Sensibility" resistive multitouch display (1024 by 600 pixels), 1.6GHz Atom N270 CPU, 2GB of DDR2 SDRAM, Intel GMA950 graphics, 32GB solid-state drive, 802.11b/g Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, 10/100 ethernet, 3G option

Other features: Front-facing 1.3-megapixel camera for videoconferencing, SD/MMC card reader, SIM card slot (for 3G option)

Size and weight: 9.8 by 6.6 by 0.8 inches (height by width by thickness); 1.8 pounds

Due: Summer 2010

Price: From $599

On paper, the Archos 9 looks impressive. Specs include a 60GB hard disk, Windows 7, a front-facing Webcam, Flash support, and a price of $549. But its 8.9-inch display is resistive and lacks multitouch, and the company appears not to have made Windows 7 more finger-friendly. Archos sells 7- and 5-inch Android-based tablets/MIDs, as well, and the company recently announced the Archos 8 Home Tablet--essentially an 8-inch touchscreen photo frame that runs Android.

OS: Windows 7 Starter Edition

Key specs: 8.9-inch LED-backlit resistive single-touch display (1024 by 600 pixels), 1.2GHz Intel Atom Z510 CPU, 1GB of DDR2 SDRAM, 60GB hard-disk drive, Intel GMA 500 graphics, 802.11b/g Wi-Fi, Bluetooth

Other features: Front-facing 1.3-megapixel Webcam for video conferencing, optical trackpoint, mouse-click and virtual keyboard buttons, mini backlight

Size and weight: 10.1 by 5.3 by 0.7 inches (height by width by thickness); 1.8 pounds

Due: Available now

Price: $549

Innovative Converged Devices' 7-inch Ultra tablet is yet another upcoming pairing of Tegra 2 and Android, but ICD's offering will emphasize affordability. The Ultra is expected to start at just $250 (without carrier subsidies) when it reaches the market at midyear. Its features will include 4GB of internal flash memory, HD video playback, and optional 3G. Interestingly, Verizon used an Ultra in January to demonstrate its next-generation 4G LTE wireless network; and the Ultra's big brother (the 15.6-inch ICD Vega) is headed to T-Mobile in the UK before the end of the year.

OS: Android 2.0

Key specs: 7-inch resistive single-touch display (1024 by 600 pixels or 800 by 480 pixels, capacitive versions are expected as well), 1GHz nVidia Tegra 2 (TegraT20) CPU, 256MB of RAM and 512MB of ROM, 4GB of internal flash memory (nonremovable), 802.11b/g Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, 3G option

Other features: Front-facing 1.3-megapixel camera for videoconferencing, mini HDMI output, microSD card slot, SIM card slot, accelerometer, FM radio, ambient light sensor, GPS option

Size and weight: 7.3 by 6.2 by 0.7 inches (height by width by thickness); 1.3 pounds or less

Due: By June 2010

Price: Expected to start at $250, without carrier subsidies

Ask Andreas Haas, the former head of Apple's Newton group, what he thinks of the iPad, and he'll tell you that "it's not a tablet; it's an extension of the iPod Touch." His company, Axiotron, is developing the Modbook Pro--a touch-enabled version of the pen-based, professionally finished Mac tablets that the business creates by converting MacBook laptops. Today you can buy pen-only Modbooks ready-made, or you can send your own MacBook to Axiotron, and the company will transform it into a Modbook for $700. The touch-capable Modbook Pro is should appear later this year, and it will probably cost quite a bit more than that.

MSI is best known for netbooks these days, so it's no surprise that the company plans to produce an as-yet-unnamed tablet. The prototype Android "mPad" shown at CES had a 10-inch touchscreen, a Tegra 2 processor, HD Flash support, and an HDMI output. The finished tablet will probably cost around $500 and may arrive later this year. No doubt we'll learn more at the Computex Taipei Expo in June. Image credit and more information: DigiTimes.

OS: Android 2.x

Key specs: 10-inch touchscreen, nVidia Tegra 2 graphics and dual-core ARM Cortex-A9 CPU, 3G, Wi-Fi

Other features: HDMI output, SD Card slot

Size and weight: Unknown

Due: Possibly second half of 2010

Price: Expected to be around $500

This Tegra 2 tablet snapped at nVidia's CES booth isn't the sexiest prototype we've ever seen, but Asus has promised to launch a "killer product" in June. Will the final Eee Pad design be the first tablet to run Google's Chrome OS? Will it use Qualcomm's Mirasol display tech for paperlike readability, except in color and with a good refresh rate? Will Asus's Waveface concept (a dual-screen netbook that unfolds into a tablet) become a real product much sooner than imagined? Perhaps the answer to all of the above questions will be no; but we should learn more come Computex time. Image credit: JKK Mobile.

OS: Likely to be either Android or Chrome OS

Key specs: Likely to have nVidia Tegra 2 graphics and dual-core ARM Cortex-A9 CPU

Other features: 3G, Wi-Fi

Size and weight: Unknown

Due: Expected in the second half of 2010

Price: Expected to be around $500 (unconfirmed by Asus)

Why would a tablet released relatively recently suddenly become 32 percent cheaper? Bad reviews: Complaints of slow performance, video playback issues, and sluggish single-touch response seem to have tarnished early hopes for the WebStation, a 7-inch Android 1.5 device designed primarily to run Web apps. For the $275 it costs (even after the price cut), you're probably better off looking at the upcoming 7-inch ICD Ultra.

OS: Android 1.5

Key specs: 7-inch resistive single-touch display (800-by-480 pixels), 624MHz Marvell PXA303 CPU, 128MB of RAM, 256MB of ROM, 802.11b/g Wi-Fi, GPS

Other features: microSD card slot (8GB card included)

Size and weight: 7.87 by 4.72 by 0.57 inches (height by width by by thickness); 13.75 ounces

Due: Available now

Price: $275 (down from $400)

Freescale makes the chips that most e-book readers (including the Kindle) use, and its upcoming i.MX508 processor--due later this year--could revolutionize eReaders. The company also envisions low-cost $200 tablet PCs, and has created this reference design for PC makers. The outline uses Freescale's ARM-based i.MX51 chip (capable of running Android, Chrome OS, or Linux), and includes a 7-inch tablet that can be docked with a keyboard base similar to Lenovo's IdeaPad U1.

OS: Chrome OS, Android, or Debian Linux with custom browser interface

Key specs: 7-inch resistive single-touch display (1024 by 600 pixels), Freescale i.MX515 (includes 800MHz ARM Cortex-A8 CPU and 720p video decoding), 512MB of RAM, 4GB to 64GB of internal storage, 802.11n Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, GPS, optional 3G

Other features: Front-facing 3-megapixel Webcam for videoconferencing, SIM card slot, three-axis accelerometer, ambient light sensor

Size and weight: 7.9 by 5.0 by 0.6 inches (height by width by thickness); 13.3 ounces

Due: Late 2010, if manufacturers pick up on the concept

Price: Reference design calls for retail prices to start at $200

What more is there to say? The iPad is a pleasure to use (despite some missing features and other faults), it hit stores on April 3, and Apple's iBooks pricing may match Amazon's. Here are the hardware specs.

OS: iPhone OS 3.2

Key specs: 9.7-inch multitouch display (1024 by 768 pixels) with IPS (in-plane switching, for better color reproduction and a wider range of viewing angles), 1GHz Apple A4 system-on-a-chip with PowerVR SGX graphics, 802.11n Wi-Fi, 3G option

Other features: Accelerometer, digital compass, ambient light sensor, Bluetooth, GPS and micro-SIM card slot (on 3G model)

Size and weight: 9.6 by 7.5 by 0.5 inches (height by width by thickness); 1.5 pounds (1.6 pounds with 3G option)

Price: $499 (with 16GB solid-state drive), $599 (with 32GB solid-state drive), $699 (with 64GB solid-state drive); add $130 for 3G option

Due: Released on April 3 (preorders started on March 12)

For additional information on the rapidly evolving product category of tablets, consult these PCWorld stories:

• "Google Pad: Search Giant Dreams of Chrome OS-based Tablets" (pictured)

• iPad vs. the iPhone: Why I Don’t Need Both--Yet

• Apple iPad Full Review

• iPad vs. Netbook: It's a Close Call

• iPad as E-Reader: Glaring Problems, Promising Apps

• 25 Most Fun and Visually Impressive iPad Games

• iPad Torture Test Video: Buy a Case and Don't Drop it!