Best on a Budget: Asus Eee PC 1001P-MU17
In a sea of nearly interchangeable 10.1-inch netbooks, the modestly priced ($299) Asus Eee PC 1001P-MU17 stands out for one thing: Express Gate, a nearly instant-on auxiliary operating system that allows quick access to the Web, online gaming, Skype, IM, and your photos. To boot to Express Gate, you start the 1001P-MU17 using a secondary power button (which has no light) on the upper left of the keyboard deck. You boot to the regular Windows 7 Starter OS via the normal lighted power button on the upper-right side.
Beyond Express Gate, the 1001P-MU17 leans mostly toward the mundane. You get the current popular netbook components: an Intel Atom N450 processor with an integrated 3150 GPU, 1GB of DDR2 memory, and a 160GB hard drive. The ports are also typical for a 10.1-inch unit: three USB, one VGA, one AC, one 10/100 ethernet jack, a single SDHC slot, plus audio in/out and a Kensington lock port.
The Eee PC 1001P-MU17 is styled in an all-black color scheme broken up only by a silver rocker button for the touchpad and a checkerboard pattern on the upper shell and lower deck. It looks as if it would be more at home in a boardroom than in a coffee shop. That's not a complaint, just a caution to anyone who might want to wow style-conscious friends.
The netbook weighs 2.8 pounds, about average for this category of netbook with a six-cell battery. If weight is more of a concern than run time, you can drop that to 2.24 pounds with a three-cell battery. However, if you plan to upgrade your machine's performance with an SSD, you might want to skip the 1001P-MU17: Unlike most netbooks, it has no access panel for the hard drive. But it does have an access panel to the memory if you want to upgrade that module.
Overall, the 1001P-MU17 felt as snappy as an N450-based netbook can when running Windows 7--you can live with it, but that's all. The WorldBench 6 score of 34, while a point higher than most, bears that out. Video performance was a touch worse than average. The Webcam's image was decently smooth, and the unit had no problem playing QuickTime or Flash HD video locally. But MP4 and WMV were a stuttering mess, as was online Flash video. Online Flash gaming was jerky to the point of distraction. Battery life was a solid 6 hours, 50 minutes--not the best we've seen, but more than enough to get you from coast to coast.
The keyboard has a crisp feel, and for some users the oversize left/right cursor keys might eliminate some hunting. The touchpad was also exceptionally well adjusted for tapping.
The model comes with Microsoft Works, which should cover most users' needs adequately (a 60-day trial version of Office 2007 is also included), and Skype is installed, as well. And thankfully, Asus has refrained from placing useless software on the desktop.
The Asus Eee PC 1001P-MU17 is a solid effort from the company that started the whole netbook craze, offering a very nice keyboard, a particularly well-adjusted touchpad, and a sedately handsome look. If you regularly need quick access to the Web, the Express Gate OS can be handy indeed. Plus, you can get the unit for just under $300.
--Jon L. Jacobi
Best for Business: HP Mini 5102
The Mini 5102 is HP's latest business-optimized netbook, with a ruggedized metal chassis and design elements tailored for the business traveler. Though packed with features that business users want, it's expensive: The configuration we reviewed, with a touchscreen, 2GB of RAM, an Atom N450 CPU, and a six-cell battery, costs about $729--easily as much as a larger, more full-featured laptop.
The lid's brushed-metal finish is handsome and doesn't attract fingerprints or smudges. The keyboard is quite easy to type on, with extra-wide <Shift>, <Backspace>, and <Enter> keys. It has a good, clicky feel with plenty of travel, but no backlight or keyboard light for working in the dark. The touchpad looks a little small (common on netbooks), but in practice it isn't much of a problem. It tracks well, and the buttons are separate, distinct, and easy to use accurately without looking at them.
The machine's display quality is slightly better than average, with decent contrast and viewing angles, but the 10.1-inch screen has a resolution of 1024 by 600, which isn't a lot of desktop real estate--it results in frequent scrolling. You can pay a bit extra for a higher-resolution, 1366-by-768 display, and it's probably worth it; that option isn't available, however, if you go for a multitouch screen.
Two USB ports are on the front left edge; on the back left edge is a VGA port. An ethernet port and a third USB port are on the back of the right edge, with headphone and microphone jacks in the middle, and a card reader up front. The front edge has only a Wi-Fi switch. Above the keyboard, you'll find a power button and two quick-launch buttons. Both 802.11n wireless networking and Bluetooth are standard. Mobile broadband with GPS by Gobi is a $125 option, but it can't be combined with some other options.
You can choose from several operating systems: SUSE Linux, Windows XP, Windows 7 Starter, and even Windows 7 Professional. Hard-drive options range from the 160GB drive of our test unit up to 320GB, or an 80GB or 120GB solid-state drive. If you deck out the system with all of the most expensive options you can combine, you'd push the price over $1100. The base model with 1GB of RAM and a four-cell battery costs $415.
With a WorldBench 6 score of 34, the performance of the Mini 5102 is similar to other netbooks using the Atom N450 processor, though the 2GB of RAM makes things a little snappier when multiple apps run. Our test unit's extended six-cell battery improves battery life: It ran for 9 hours, 41 minutes in our tests. As on other Atom-based netbooks, the graphics and video decoding is quite poor.
Though its design and feature set are good, especially for business users, all but the barest configurations of the HP Mini 5102 cost as much as many full-size laptops that perform much better. The Mini 5102 is a great netbook for simple note-taking and document editing on the go, as well as for long business flights, but if you just want an inexpensive companion PC, you'll be better off considering less-pricey models.
Best for Entertainment: Asus Eee PC 1201N
Would you spend almost $500 for a netbook-even a top-of-the-line one, like the Asus Eee PC 1201N? At first blush, the 1201N physically resembles more-conventional thin-and-light laptops based on low-voltage (CULV) mainstream CPUs. It's certainly priced in that ballpark, at $480 to $499; it has both a crisp, 12.1-inch, 1366-by-768-resolution display and one of the better keyboards that I've seen on a netbook, too. It also has a 1.6GHz Intel Atom N330 processor--one, however, that is hosted by the capable nVidia Ion chipset.
The Ion's video capability, Asus hopes, is what will bring buyers to the table. In our tests, its video performance and image quality were definitely a cut above those of Atom CPUs using the stock Intel chipset. The Ion chipset delivers robust video quality, giving smooth performance and downscaling with 1080p WMV files. The Ion's 3D gaming performance was also better, but this is not a gaming system.
The bigger display means slightly larger dimensions than many netbooks have, giving the keyboard a more usable layout than those of many netbooks with a 10-inch screen. And the larger display with its higher pixel count makes for a more productive working environment--you spend less time scrolling and more time reading Web pages and documents.
The ports are typical for a netbook, consisting of three USB ports, an HDMI digital video port, and a VGA analog graphics connector, plus, on the right side, an ethernet jack, audio in/out, and a multiformat flash memory reader.
This Eee PC ships with SRS audio and the full Realtek HD audio suite, allowing you to set specific equalization settings and to spread out the sound field a bit. I found that enabling these features muddied the sound quality, however, so I usually left the settings on standard stereo. The system's built-in speakers won't make you cringe, but you'll enjoy better sound by using headphones.
The LCD screen offers better-than-adequate image quality, but it's also very sensitive to viewing angles. That can make casual video viewing on your couch a little frustrating, as you must either stay in the same position or constantly adjust the display to the appropriate angle every time you shift your body.
Asus ships the machine with Windows 7 Home Premium instead of the more typical Windows 7 Starter Edition or Windows XP. Home Premium offers more customization choices-something welcome in a product that positions itself at the high end of its category.
Microsoft Works and Microsoft Office trialware come bundled. Also included is Asus Webstorage, an online file backup and sync service that provides 1GB of free storage. The 1201N's performance earned it a WorldBench 6 score of 33. Battery life, at 4 hours, 17 minutes in our testing, seemed a tad short for current-generation netbooks.
The real problem with the 1201N is its cost. At nearly $500, the price tag encroaches on the cost of laptops with CULV (ultralow voltage) mainstream processors, such as Lenovo's ThinkPad Edge and Dell's Vostro V13. Though this Eee PC gives you a bigger display and a more usable keyboard, CULV notebooks are likely to outperform it.
Some people will find the Asus Eee PC 1201N's video performance and 12-inch display to be compelling. But I'd still like to see the netbook's price drop by about $100.
Check These Out, Too
Here are alternative netbook models--one in each of our five categories--that are also worth your consideration.
Design: Samsung N210
Sold only at Best Buy, this all-white, $379 model is one of the better-looking netbooks we've seen, and it has a comfortable keyboard and a quick-start feature.
Battery Life: Gateway LT2120u
This $350, Windows 7 Starter netbook lasted an impressive 9 hours, 40 minutes in our battery tests; it's also relatively good at handling video.
Budget: Toshiba Mini NB305-N310
Priced at just $349, this model offers good battery life, a keyboard with large keys, a touchpad that supports multitouch gestures, and a nice software bundle.
Business: Lenovo ThinkPad X100e
With faster performance, a bigger hard drive, and a larger, higher-resolution screen than most netbooks, this model costs more, as well (prices start at $499).
Entertainment: MSI Wind12 U230
This $430 model with Windows 7 Home Premium has the performance of an ultraportable in the chassis of a netbook--but its battery life is short.