Ultimate guide to SSDs (plus reviews of 7 new drives!)

Jon L. Jacobi

Jon L. JacobiJon Jacobi, PCWorld

Jon L. Jacobi has worked with computers since you flipped switches and punched cards to program them. He studied music at Julliard, and now he power mods his car for kicks.
More by Jon L. Jacobi

Installing an SSD in your PC, be it a laptop or a desktop, is one of the easiest and most effective ways to boost the machine’s overall performance. The change won't be merely noticeable—it will startle you. Your system will boot more quickly, windows and menus will jump open, and programs and data will load much, much faster.

In case you don’t know what an SSD is, the acronym stands for solid-state drive—that is, solid-state as in no moving parts, and drive as in the fact that an SSD appears as a hard drive to your computer. But instead of storing data on one or more spinning platters, an SSD writes and reads data to and from nonvolatile flash memory. In addition, an SSD contains a controller that's analogous to the memory controller in your PC’s CPU or core-logic chipset.

Many vendors sell SSDs, but the devices are far from equal. Flash memory and controller technology have both advanced so quickly that what was fast last year is now second-class. The drives you might find in the bargain bin will be faster than a consumer-grade mechanical hard drive, but they won't deliver the astounding performance boost you'll be looking for after you read this article.

To get the skinny on state-of-the-art consumer SSDs, we brought seven drives from five vendors into the PCWorld Labs and put them through the wringer. We tested Corsair’s Neutron and Neutron GTX drives; Kingston's HyperX 3K; OCZ's Vertex 4 and Vector drives; Samsung’s 840 Pro; and the SanDisk Extreme. We also retested Intel’s 240GB Series 335 SSD using our new benchmarking procedure (if you're curious, read our original review). Each drive delivers either 240GB or 256GB of storage, which is the current sweet spot in terms of price and performance. Each drive we tested proved to be a solid performer that will offer a significant boost over whatever conventional drive your machine has now. Some drives, however, are definitely faster than others.

If you’d like to upgrade a computer equipped with an older second-generation SATA interface (which maxes out at 3 gigbits per second), note that we also checked out the Apricorn Velocity Solo x2, an add-in card that upgrades any computer with an available PCIe 2.0 x2 slot to the newer SATA 6-gbps standard.

But before we dive into those reviews, here’s a primer on SSDs that will tell you everything you need to know about this technology.

Controller

The memory/interface controller proved to be a major factor in determining each SSD's performance. Three of the drives we tested use a SandForce SF-2281 controller: the Kingston HyperX 3K, the SanDisk Extreme, and the Intel Series 335 (the controller firmware on this drive is tweaked to Intel’s specifications). OCZ’s Vector and Vertex 4 drives both use OCZ's proprietary IndiLinx controllers, namely the Everest 2 in the Vertex 4 and the Barefoot 3 in the Vector. Corsair is blazing a path with its Neutron series drives (the GTX and Neutron) by using Link A Media's LM87800 controller. Samsung's 840 Pro utilizes the company's proprietary MDX controller.

As you'll see in our performance chart, drives with the IndiLinx, Link A Media, and Samsung MDX controllers boasted significantly faster write speeds than the SandForce-based competition. In fact, counterintuitively, each of the five drives using those controllers wrote faster than they read. The SandForce-based drives were all good readers, but their comparatively slower write speeds dragged down their overall scores.

On the next page (scroll down past product-reviews for the link), I'll discuss memory types, interfaces, and how we measured performance.

Bottom Line

Corsair's Neutron offers a very nice price-to-performance ratio. It's fast enough to give your system a kick in the pants without unduly straining your wallet.

*Price when rated

$190

Pros

  • A very good performer overall
  • Affordably priced

Cons

  • Not as fast as its cousin, the Neutron GTX

Bottom Line

If you're looking for top-flight performance on a budget, the Corsair Neutron GTX is currently the pick of the litter.

*Price when rated

$230

Pros

  • A fast performer overall
  • Budget priced considering its performance
  • Carries a five-year warranty

Cons

  • One of the slower drives when writing our large batch of files and folders
  • Link a Media is a lesser-known controller brand, at least in the consumer market

Bottom Line

If you're not insisting on absolute bleeding-edge performance, the HyperX 3K is easily one of the best deals going for an SSD.

*Price when rated

$184

Pros

  • A good overall performer
  • Includes cables and an external enclosure

Cons

  • Slow write performance
  • Only a three-year warranty

Bottom Line

If you're an enthusiast looking for top performance, this is a drive you should be thinking about.

*Price when rated

$270

Pros

  • Very fast
  • 7mm height suitable for thin-and-lights
  • 16GB more capacity than much of the competition

Cons

  • High price per gigabyte
  • Drive not discounted at time of review

Bottom Line

The OCZ Vertex 4 currently sits at the sweet spot for SSDs: It's very fast and relatively affordable, and it has 16GB more capacity than many of its competitors.

*Price when rated

$195

Pros

  • Fast
  • Strong price/performance ratio
  • 16GB more capacity than much of the competition

Cons

  • Slow when reading our collection of small files and folders
  • Only a three-year warranty

Bottom Line

The Samsung 840 Pro is currently the fastest consumer SSD on the market. You pay a bit more for it, but you always pay more for the best.

*Price when rated

$260

Pros

  • Fastest SSD in our December 2012 roundup
  • 7mm thickness makes it compatible with thin-and-light laptops
  • Five-year warranty

Cons

  • The most expensive SSD in our December 2012 roundup
  • Not dramatically faster than the second-place SSD in our December 2012 roundup

Bottom Line

Although it's only an average performer, the inexpensive SanDisk Extreme delivers tremendous bang for your SSD buck.

*Price when rated

$165

Pros

  • Very low price per gigabyte
  • Much faster than previous-generation SSDs

Cons

  • Mediocre write performance
  • Nothing extra in the box, not even mounting screws

Bottom Line

Intel's move to 20nm NAND flash renders higher-capacity SSDs more affordable.

*Price when rated

$184

Pros

  • Lower cost per gigabyte than Intel's previous-generation SSDs
  • Free Intel SSD Toolbox and data migration software

Cons

  • 9.5mm profile renders it too thick for ultraportables
  • SSDs remain considerably more expensive than mechanical hard drives

Bottom Line

If your PC doesn't have a SATA 6-gbps interface, this device adds it, caddies one drive, and let's you attach another via a cable.

*Price when rated

$95

Pros

  • Adds SATA 6-gbps capability to older desktop motherboards
  • Caddies a single SSD
  • Includes a second 6-gbps interface to host another drive

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Requires at least a x2 PCIe slot

Add Your Comment

user avatar