New data center survey shows mediocre results for energy efficiency

A new survey suggests that large data centers might be less energy efficient than was previously thought.

The survey, by Digital Realty Trust, quizzed 300 IT decision makers at large corporations in North America, each with annual revenue of at least $1 billion or with at least 5000 employees.

The results revealed an average PUE (Power Usage Effectiveness) score of 2.9. PUE is a measure of data center efficiency, and lower scores are better. Ideal scores are close to 1.0, and previous surveys have estimated the average to be closer to 2.0.

PUE is only one way of measuring energy efficiency and there’s no standardized way of calculating it, so the finding isn’t necessarily dire. But it’s a data point suggesting that data centers might be less efficient on average than previously thought.

The Uptime Institute, in a survey last year of 1,100 data center users, reported an average PUE of 1.8 to 1.89. That was an improvement over 2.5 in its 2007 survey. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, in 2009, reportedly put the average PUE at 1.91.

Big online firms such as Google and Microsoft have boasted of PUEs of close to 1.0, but they’re special cases. Many of the data centers they operate are new, and they invest heavily in IT efficiency, since it affects so much of their overall operating costs.

“While a PUE of 2.9 seems terribly inefficient, we view it as more being closer to the norm than the extremely low (close to 1) figures reported in the media,” said Jim Smith, Digital Realty’s CTO, via email. “In our view, those figures represent what a very small number of organizations can achieve based on a unique operating model.”

The survey also showed that 20 percent of respondents reported having a PUE of less than 2.0, while 9 percent had a PUE of 4.0 or greater.

PUE is a ratio that looks at the total energy supplied to a data center, divided by the amount of energy that actually reaches the IT equipment. It reveals how much energy is expended on cooling systems and other noncompute functions. A PUE of 2.0 means that for every 2 watts supplied to the data center, only 1 watt reaches the computing equipment.

The average from this week’s survey can be attributed to older designs and equipment, under-utilized assets, and other design and operating issues, Smith said. There are other factors, too. The figures reported “reinforce the fact that IT is not easy. Designing data center operations around an organization’s infrastructure and operations is not a simple task,” he said.

The main focus for many data centers is making sure that services remain available, he added. That can mean installing redundant equipment, which creates inefficiency.

Despite the relatively poor PUE score, Digital Realty’s survey points to increased efforts to improve efficiency. Four out of five respondents said they take steps to keep hot exhaust air from servers mixing with cold air used for cooling, known as hot-aisle or cold-aisle containment. That was up from less than two-thirds in 2011. And 85 percent use some type of data center infrastructure management software, an emerging class of products that can be used to improve efficiency.

Other findings include:

  • Nearly all respondents, 98 percent, said they plan to expand their data centers in 2013 or 2014, the highest percentage in the seven years Digital Realty has sponsored the survey;
  • 65 percent would prefer to locate a new or expanded data center in New York City;
  • Among international locations, London (39 percent), Hong Kong (34 percent) and Tokyo (27 percent) were mentioned most often;
  • 66 percent have built or acquired a new data center in the past two years;
  • A quarter of respondents reported operating six or more data centers, not including “IT closets” in branch offices;
  • The average power density is 8.5 kW per rack, and the average IT load is 2.6 mW, both up from last year.

Subscribe to the Business Brief Newsletter

Comments