Wireless Charging Powers Forward for Mobile Devices
Hands On With Wireless Chargers
I spent several weeks using three different wireless charging platforms, from Energizer, Powermat, and Duracell. The charging mats and the necessary charging sleeves enabled me to experience a life without wires--almost.
The total cost of any of these three wireless charging products can vary by $25 or more, depending on the number and types of devices you wish to charge as well as on whether you take advantage of components such as rechargeable, portable batteries. In general you can expect a basic setup, including the charging mat and the appropriate charging sleeve for your smartphone, to run just under $100.
Energizer Qi ($90): The Energizer Qi is compliant with the Wireless Power Consortium standard. That's a plus for the Energizer system--assuming that other Qi-enabled devices or charging mats soon become available to take advantage of it. As long as my Energizer Qi mat and my Energizer Qi iPhone 4 sleeve ($35) are all that I can work with, it's really no different from the proprietary Powermat system.
I really like the look and feel of the Energizer Qi iPhone 4 sleeve, which is smooth, solid, and a nice fit on the phone. It does add some heft, though: The sleeve weighs about twice as much as the Powermat's iPhone 4 sleeve, adding just over an ounce to the total weight of the smartphone.
I had two big issues with the Energizer Qi system. First, the charging mat itself is big (it's fairly flat, but it takes up about as much space as a sheet of paper) and not aesthetically pleasing. It isn't the sort of thing I want visible in my home as a permanent fixture. The second, much larger problem is that you have no way to sync the iPhone 4 with iTunes or your PC while it is in the Energizer Qi iPhone 4 sleeve. For other smartphones that can sync wirelessly--which in all fairness the iPhone should be able to do--this obviously would not be an issue.
Powermat 2x Mat with Powercube ($70): The Powermat charging system, on the other hand, has a Micro-USB connector in the bottom of the iPhone 4 charging sleeve. It comes equipped with a USB-to-Micro-USB cord so that you can still connect the iPhone 4 to your PC and sync its data without having to remove the phone from the charging sleeve. Of course, the irony of needing a wire to maintain the functionality of my smartphone while using it with my "wireless" charging system is not lost on me.
The Powermat charging system is much more versatile than the Energizer Qi. Sleeves for a variety of smartphones are available, ranging in price from $20 to $40; the assortment covers iPhones as well as Android and BlackBerry handsets. Plus, you can find charging sleeves for the Nintendo DS and DS Lite, an inductive charging dock for the iPod and iPhone, and a universal charging module for devices that aren't equipped with sleeves. Powermat also offers a portable rechargeable battery that you can charge wirelessly and then carry as an emergency backup for your mobile device.
As with the Energizer system, I have two complaints about the Powermat. The first problem is with the flip-down top of the iPhone 4 sleeve, where the device slides in; it clips on too snugly, and getting the iPhone 4 in and out of the charging sleeve is a pain. The flip-down part seems unnecessary. The other issue is that Powermat's technology is proprietary--although I like the Powermat system more than the Energizer Qi system today, I would rather invest in a standardized platform that doesn't lock me in to one vendor.
Duracell MyGrid Cell Phone Starter Kit ($57): Falling somewhere between the Qi and the Powermat is the Duracell MyGrid charging system. The MyGrid cell phone starter kit comes with a MyGrid power clip and the necessary adapters to connect with a variety of BlackBerry, Motorola, and Nokia handsets. Similar to Powermat, Duracell also offers a rechargeable portable battery capable of providing up to 35 hours of additional power.
Unlike the other two wireless charging systems, the Duracell MyGrid uses conductive, rather than inductive, technology. Power transfers from metal strips on the MyGrid charging mat to metal contacts on the charging sleeve or clip, but the MyGrid mat is engineered so that it's safe to touch and not a shock hazard.
The charging sleeve for the iPhone 4 is a lightweight, flexible rubber case. It's my favorite of the three; like the Energizer Qi sleeve, however, it does not provide any way of syncing the iPhone 4 while the handset is in the case.
Duracell's charging mat is less sleek and attractive than Powermat's system, but it has the advantage of being able to charge up to four devices simultaneously. And it's less picky about where or how devices should rest on it in order for them to connect and charge.
The MyGrid seemed to charge a little faster than the other two products did. Recharge times on the Duracell were more like plugging my iPhone 4 into the wall, while the Powermat and Energizer models were somewhat slower--more like charging the iPhone 4 with a USB cable connected to my PC.
Wireless charging for mobile devices is cool and has potential, but currently it doesn't really make life more efficient or convenient. Instead of having to connect your smartphone to a charging cord, you have to make sure you have the right charging sleeve. Instead of needing the right adapter and connector to juice up your gadget, you require the appropriate charging mat. These are the same drawbacks as with wired charging, but with different items to remember.
For my iPhone 4, in fact, cord-free charging actually adds complexity. Instead of connecting the phone to my PC via USB cable and then charging, syncing, and backing it up simultaneously while I sleep, I now have to charge the phone wirelessly, and then connect it to the PC to sync and backup. That might even require removing the charging sleeve, depending on the wireless charging platform.
"It is about time some sort of standard emerges for charging devices," says Al Hilwa, an analyst for research firm IDC, adding that vendors have had little financial incentive to adapt a shared standard.
However, the Qi standard has major backing--including from Duracell, Energizer, Motorola, Nokia, and Samsung--so the future looks bright.
If Qi gains momentum, then smartphone, tablet, and laptop vendors will simply build Qi-compatible inductive charging functionality into the cases of their devices, eliminating the need for external charging sleeves.
The Wireless Power Consortium envisions incorporating Qi into a wide range of settings, including homes, hotels, airports, convenience stores, and restaurant chains. Imagine if automobile manufacturers built Qi-compatible charging into vehicles.
Wireless charging everywhere could be great--but today it remains a cool, niche novelty.
In Video: Powermat Eliminates Charging Cables
Products mentioned in this article