capsule review

Xerox Phaser 6500DN: High-Volume Features, but High-Priced Toner

At a Glance
  • Generic Company Place Holder Xerox Phaser 6500DN Laser Printer

    PCWorld Rating

    This workgroup-level printer imposes budget-breaking toner costs, making it unsuitable for high-volume use.

Xerox's Phaser 6500DN color laser printer for small and medium-size workgroups carries a temptingly low price of $499 (as of February 22, 2011). But given the volume of output that such users are likely to generate, it's unfortunate that the Phaser 6500DN's replacement toner costs are so dear. (In contrast, Xerox's larger Phaser 7500DN, which we reviewed back in mid-2009, has an extremely high selling price but offers very reasonably priced replacement toner.)

The Phaser 6500DN provides the usual workgroup-level features: USB and ethernet connectivity; a 250-sheet main input tray and integrated manual-feed slot; and a top, 150-sheet output tray. An additional, 250-sheet input tray costs $199 from Xerox. Duplexing (two-sided printing) is standard, but Mac users must enable it manually. The Phaser 6500, a lower-cost model without duplexing, costs $399.

In our tests, the Phaser 6500DN delivered midrange speeds on the PC platform: It produced 14.8 pages per minute of plain text, and 1.8 ppm of snapshot-size color photos on letter-size paper. Mac performance was slower than average: 13.1 ppm when printing plain text; 2.7 ppm when printing a document with mixed text and graphics; and a sluggish 0.4 ppm when printing a high-resolution, full-page color photo.

Though the unit's print speed numbers weren't bad, our sample output revealed a few print quality challenges. Plain, black text was perfectly crisp, but solid areas in either grayscale or color showed slight banding on the PC platform, and inkjet-printer-like graininess on the Mac platform. Color quality was realistic, but initially we encountered registration problems (the four colors failed to line up), making images look blurry or off-kilter. The printer has automatic and manual methods for fixing this, but after a couple of rounds of attempted corrections, we still couldn't perfect it. Per Xerox, it might take two or three cycles to set things straight.

Even when you get the colors right, the cost of printing with them will be high, to judge from the pricing released by Xerox at press time. The printer ships with 1000-page cartridges for all four colors. The 3000-page replacement black cartridge costs $106, or a pricey 3.5 cents per page. The two sizes of color cartridges include 1000-page models for $65 apiece (6.5 cents per color), and 2,500-page models for $110 apiece (4.4 cents per color). A four-color page would cost between 16.7 and 23 cents. These prices more closely resemble those of a typical color inkjet printer than of a typical color laser.

The Xerox Phaser 6500DN is equipped for busy workgroup use. Unfortunately, its color costs make higher-volume usage prohibitively expensive. The Oki C610dtn, or a lower-cost variant, is a similar model with lower-priced toner (but other shortcomings).

To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
At a Glance
  • PCWorld Rating

    This workgroup-level printer imposes budget-breaking toner costs, making it unsuitable for high-volume use.

    Pros

    • Expandable paper handling

    Cons

    • Expensive toner
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.