AT&T, Where's the Pooled Data Plan with Rollover Megabytes?

AT&T has pulled the plug on unlimited data for its home DSL and Uverse customers. The move to capped data comes only nine months after AT&T ended unlimited access for its mobile data plans, and sets a concerning precedent. For me, though, it just begs the question of why AT&T can't bundle those things up for a better deal.

AT&T residential customers have enjoyed unlimited data up to now, but--according to AT&T--the vast majority of its customers only use about 18GB per month. AT&T claims that only two percent of its customers will come close to exceeding the 150GB cap for DSL, or the 250GB cap on Uverse data. The AT&T statistics are similar to the numbers AT&T shared about mobile data consumption--where supposedly only two percent of the AT&T wireless customers need more than 2GB per month of data.

Data is data is data--so why do I have to pay for separate plans for each device?
I switched two of the three smartphones on my AT&T family plan to the 200MB data plan when AT&T switched things up. They weren't using that much anyway, so switching plans allowed me to save $15 a month on each device. After exceeding the 200MB cap a couple times, I eventually upgraded one of the two to the 2GB plan--plenty of data and still $5 less than I was paying for unlimited.

But, now I am paying $30 for unlimited data on one phone, $25 for 2GB of data on the second, and $15 for 200MB of data on the third, plus $45 a month for 12Mbps data through Uverse which is now capped at 250GB. Assume for a minute that I changed my unlimited plan to the 2GB plan--I would be paying $110 per month for a combined total of 254.2GB of data. But, according to AT&T, odds are good that I only really need less than 20GB between all of the devices combined.

Of course, I haven't yet taken into account that I am also paying an additional $30 a month for unlimited text messaging on the wireless family plan. A text message is just data--and, in fact, AT&T reports text message usage within the data usage when viewing account data--so I am not really sure why I have to pay for it separate from the data I am already paying for. Add that in, and we're looking at $140 per month for massive data capacity that I am using only a fraction of.

Then, there are the additional fees for tethering. AT&T is now offering a $45 data plan that includes the 2GB plan plus an additional 2GB for a combined total of 4Gb of data capacity that can be shared across multiple devices using the Wi-Fi hotspot functionality in phones like the iPhone 4. But, what if I don't need any additional data capacity? Why can't I just turn on the hotspot and share my base 2GB with other devices without paying more money?

I think AT&T is on to something, though, with the rollover minutes it offers on the voice plans. I have a pool of minutes that are shared between all of my mobile phones, and the minutes we don't use carry over to the next month. So, AT&T--when can we drop the pretense of treating residential and wireless data separately, or paying for each device individually, and get something similar for data plans?

How about a pooled data plan? Give me some tiered options--say 50GB, 150GB, and 250GB--and let me buy a combined data plan that is shared between my home and mobile devices, and let my unused megabytes rollover to the next month.

Oh, and stop pretending that a text message isn't just another form of data.

To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
Shop Tech Products at Amazon
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.