Netgear XAVB5201 HomePlug Ethernet adapter review: Squeezing better performance from an old standard

Netgear XAV5201
Credit: Michael Brown
At a Glance
  • Netgear XAVB5201 Powerline 500 Mbps Adapter

    TechHive Rating

    Netgear uses proprietary tweaks to squeeze better-than-average performance from the older HomePlug AV standard.

Netgear’s current power-line offering is based on the HomePlug AV spec with enhancements that bring theoretical speeds up to 500 Mbps (hence the product name). When I asked why the company hadn’t introduced an AV2 product, the answer was that Netgear considered these adapters competitive with other vendors’ first-generation AV2 gear.

Our tests showed this claim to be only slightly exaggerated in terms of performance: TCP throughput was in the low 60 Mbps range, or about 5 to 6 Mbps slower than the speeds of the first-generation AV2 products in this roundup. That’s generally in line with what HomePlug Powerline Alliance officials told us to expect in terms of performance differences between enhanced HomePlug AV and basic AV2.

netgear xavb5201

The performance of Netgear's XAVB5201 power-line Ethernet adapter is very good, considering its based on the older HomePlug AV standard. On the other hand, it's based on the older HomePlug AV standard. 

The adapters in the Netgear XAVB5201 starter kit are somewhat smaller than the others in this roundup, which makes it easier to use the second receptacle in the typical wall outlet. Netgear provides long (about 6.5 feet) ethernet cables, pushbutton and password security options, and the typical three LED lights to indicate power, power-line network, and ethernet connections.

While its $90 MSRP seemed a bit high for older-generation technology that falls slightly short of newer products in terms of performance, street prices are falling fast (no doubt helped by Netgear’s CES product announcements).

Given that the performance difference may not matter for most people, the XAVB5201 could be an attractive buy if its price falls below that of the AV2 competition—and if you’re not planning on adding additional adapters from other vendors that might not support the proprietary technology that makes this product so competitive.

Homeplug price chart

This story, "Netgear XAVB5201 HomePlug Ethernet adapter review: Squeezing better performance from an old standard" was originally published by TechHive.

To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
At a Glance
  • TechHive Rating

    Netgear uses proprietary tweaks to squeeze better-than-average performance from the older HomePlug AV standard.

    Pros

    • Fast performance
    • Small form factor

    Cons

    • Proprietary enhancements
Related:
Notice to our Readers
We're now using social media to take your comments and feedback. Learn more about this here.