- Recommend:
- 0 Comments
Napster's Fate Remains Undecided
Attorneys make arguments, but appeals court delays ruling on immediate fate of music-sharing site.
SAN FRANCISCO -- There's no word yet on whether music-sharing site Napster must change its tune.
A U.S. federal appeals court on Monday heard arguments from both sides but did not rule on whether to continue an injunction barring the site from operating.
The three-judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals here is expected to rule soon on whether Napster must shut down. In July, Judge Marilyn Hall Patel issued the injunction, ordering that Napster remove copyrighted material from music labels represented by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), the plaintiffs in the lawsuit.
Napster quickly appealed Patel's ruling and wound up before the appellate court on Monday. The case will go to trial later this year.
The RIAA and record labels it represents contend that Napster is violating copyrights and engaging in piracy.
"We don't think it's piracy because we think it is lawful [use of material]," Napster attorney David Boies argued before the appellate court on Monday.
Further, Napster lawyers contend that some 15 percent of the songs on Napster are not copyrighted, and 20,000 artists have given the Web site permission to use their music. The peer-to-peer technology offered by Napster is important, and it should be the business of the U.S. Congress to provide legislation regarding its use, not the job of the courts, attorneys argued.
But the issue isn't about technology, said Russell Frackman, an attorney for plaintiff A&M Records. "We're talking about a business and a business plan," he said, adding that Napster was created with the intent of sharing copyrighted material.
Would you recommend this story? YES NO
- Recommend:
- 0 Comments
-
Speed Up Everything!
PCWorld shows you the secrets to improve performance on all your hardware.
-
Lenovo IdeaPad
See why the IdeaPad tablet is optimized for ultimate entertainment.
-
ThinkPad Edge E420 Lenovo Style in an Affordable Package
Buy now direct from Lenovo -
ThinkPad X220 Fast and light, with great input ergonomics and battery life, this powerhouse ultraportable is best-of-breed.
Buy now direct from Lenovo -
ThinkPad X120e One of the best netbooks ever, X120e has the best netbook keyboard ever--nothing else comes close
Buy now direct from Lenovo
- RIAA Thinks LimeWire Owes $75 Trillion in Damages
- Requiem for Napster
- He's the Lawyer Who Nailed Napster
- Copyright Cops Target Workplace, Schools
- The Napster Knockoffs: Are Their Tunes Different?
- Anti-Napster Ruling Draws Mixed Reaction
- File-Sharing Site MegaUpload Indicted for Internet Piracy, Shut Down by US
- 12 Criteria for Selecting the Best ERP System Replacement An ERP system is your information backbone and reaches into all areas of your business and value chain. Replacing it can open unlimited business opportunities. This white paper explains the 12 criteria that allow you to identify and select the solution that will meet these expectations.
- Leveraging Social Computing Technologies for ERP Applications This white paper details how Web 2.0 technologies support business strategies by improving efficiency, productivity, and collaboration.















