Security Code Crackers Warned to Keep Mum
After hosting hacking contest, music labels tell winners to keep their winning methods quiet.
Keith Dawson, Industry Standard
Last year the recording industry waved the Digital Millennium Copyright Act at a bunch of hackers, Linux advocates, and other assorted lowlifes. This year the labels are going uptown: The Secure Digital Music Initiative is threatening a Princeton University professor with legal action if his group publishes its research results.
The dispute is over a contest the SDMI ran last fall, in which the world was invited to hack six digital watermarking techniques that were under development. The SDMI set stringent limits on what participants could do and how much they could say afterwards; the Princeton-led team said it never agreed to any such limits.
An SDMI lawyer, Matthew Oppenheim, sent a letter to the lead researcher, Edward Felton, warning that if the group published details of its research, it might be liable under the DMCA. Most media outlets stressed the DMCA threat in their coverage; only a few detailed the other aspect of the legal warning, that the researchers may have violated the agreement that SDMI insisted contest participants "sign" (actually click through) before attempting to crack its watermarking protections.
On Friday a copy of the letter, and an early draft of the researchers' paper, showed up on Cryptome.org, the Web site of a New York activist.
Coverage Avoids Specifics
Some media outlets contented themselves with interviewing Felton and Oppenheim. Inside delved more deeply, noting that the Princeton-led group was not the only team scheduled to present SDMI-cracking results in Pittsburgh on April 25. Inside's Charles C. Mann and Roger Parloff interviewed the leader of a French team that claims to have cracked three of the SDMI's six challenges (Felton's team managed four), and who has long since posted full research results on the Web.
While a number of stories alluded to the earlier DMCA case involving the DVD-cracking code DeCSS, Inside was the only outlet, among those the Industry Standard discovered, to note that the watermarking technology involved in the SDMI affair is different from the encryption technology used in DeCSS.
For cryptography, researchers can examine and publish details of the algorithms involved without destroying the usefulness of code. But for watermarking technology, continued secrecy turns out to be all-important.
For more in-depth coverage of the Internet Economy, visit The Industry Standard.
Laptop Showcase
Perfect Print Solutions
- Great year-end deals for small business!

-
Get 24/7 live remote AT&T Tech Support 360* service along with select Lenovo* PCs (with Intel® Core™ 2 Duo processors and save up to 200!
-
HP EliteBook* 6930p Notebook with Intel® vPro™ technology and a free HP Basic Docking Station - $641 instant savings!
- *Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others. ©2009 Intel Corporation. Intel, the Intel logo, vPro and Core trademarks of Intel Corporation in the United States and other countries. All rights reserved.
Dell Fast Track
-
Free Next Day Business Shipping on Dell's Most Popular Systems
Over 35% off Dell’s most popular systems. Delivered in 48 hours with free next business day shipping! Ends 12/22 at 3 PM CST
People who read this also read:
Best Prices on TVs
LN46B500 46" LCD TVPrice: $799.99
LC-42SB45UT 42" LCD TVPrice: $679.00
DX-L32-10A 32" LCD TVPrice: $299.99
UN55B8000 55" LED TVPrice: $2495.00
PN50B650 50" Plasma TVPrice: $1115.99
LN52B750 52" LCD TVPrice: $1759.00
- Perfect Printing Solutions Find just the right All-in-One Printer for you from HP. Visit the HP Resource Center.
- Acer Laptop Center Forget the Mouse...check out the next generation multi-gesture touch screen technology from Acer.
- Dell Shopping Center Check out great deals from Dell!
Cameras
Camcorders
Cell Phones
Components
Desktops
HDTV
Home Theater
GPS
Laptops
Monitors
MP3 Players
Networking &
Printers
Storage







