Judge Orders Music-Sharing KaZaA to Cease
Techology's owners unsure how to comply, since software is merely enabler.
Joris Evers, IDG News Service
AMSTERDAM, NETHERLANDS -- The makers of popular file-sharing software KaZaA must make it impossible for users to continue to share copyright-protected material using the software, or pay a fine for each day the product remains unchanged, a Dutch judge has ordered.
The case was brought to the Amsterdam district court by Buma/Stemra, an organization that represents composers, songwriters, and music publishers in the Netherlands. Judge R. Orobio de Castro ruled Thursday that because KaZaA does not have a license from Buma/Stemra it is acting unlawfully by making software available that allows users to download music files.
KaZaA has 14 days to comply with the order. If it doesn't, the company will have to pay $40,000 each day, to a maximum of $500,000, the judge ruled.
KaZaA is puzzled by the verdict and it doesn't understand exactly what to do, said KaZaA's attorney Christiaan Alberdingk Thijm.
"Our software can't disappear, it is already out there," he said. "And the minute we take down our Web site, mirrors will appear."
Uncertain Response
KaZaA is so-called peer-to-peer (P-to-P) software that allows users to search each other's hard drives for files they want and to download those. KaZaA doesn't require a central server to work, unlike Napster, which was shut down when it installed filters on its servers after a legal battle in the United States.
"At trial, we asked the judge to be clear in his verdict if he was going to side with Buma/Stemra. Now we don't know what to do. Should we go door-to-door and ask people to stop using the software? Should we put a notice on our Web site? Whatever we do, it will always lead to a new conflict with Buma/Stemra," Alberdingk Thijm said.
KaZaA is weighing its options and might appeal, Alberdingk Thijm said.
A spokesman for Buma/Stemra declined to comment, saying the company had not yet studied the verdict.
Users won't be affected by the verdict, said Lee Black, research director at analyst firm Webnoize, who called the ruling the fruit of "a judicial system that doesn't understand the technology it is trying to regulate."
"You could take down the KaZaA Web site and prevent anybody from downloading the application from there, but you can't prevent users from launching the client and accessing the network," he said.
P-to-P Booms
KaZaA is based on P-to-P technology developed by Amsterdam-based FastTrack BV, which is closely related to KaZaA. Two other P-to-P applications, MusicCity Networks's Morpheus and Grokster's Grokster, also use FastTrack's technology. Thursday's verdict does not affect those products, according to Alberdingk Thijm.
Applications based on FastTrack's technology are rapidly gaining popularity, according to Webnoize. Consumers transferred 1.81 billion digital media files using any of the three applications during October, a rise of 20 percent from the 1.51 billion files downloaded during September, according to Webnoize, which estimates that about 500,000 people use KaZaA at any given moment.
There is a way to kill KaZaA, Morpheus and Grokster all at once, according to Webnoize's Black. Copyright holders have to go after FastTrack.
"KaZaA is just the consumer-facing side, FastTrack is the P-to-P stack and has demonstrated in the past that it can change the configuration of its network to lock out an old version of an application," he said. "The next judge's order will be for FastTrack to change the network."
In the United States, the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) and the Motion Picture Association of America (MPAA) have filed suit against KaZaA, Morpheus, and Grokster.
Save on Printing Costs
Microsoft Office Home and Student 2007
- Great year-end deals

for small business! -
Get 24/7 live remote AT&T Tech Support 360* service along with select Lenovo* PCs (with Intel® Core™ 2 Duo processors) and save up to 200!
-
HP EliteBook* 6930p Notebook with Intel® vPro™ technology and a free HP Basic Docking Station - $641 instant savings!
- *Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others. ©2009 Intel Corporation. Intel, the Intel logo, vPro and Core trademarks of Intel Corporation in the United States and other countries. All rights reserved.
Dell End of Year Deals
-
Ring in the New Year with Huge Deals on Dell Computers
Up to 30% Popular Dell Laptops, up to 25% off Popular Dell Desktops. Sales ends 12/31 5AM EST.
People who read this also read:
Camcorders
VIXIA HF200 SD/SDHC HD CamcorderPrice: $548.00
VIXIA HF20 32GB Flash Drive HD CamcorderPrice: $654.95
UltraHD 8GB Flash Drive HD Camcorder - BlackPrice: $149.99
Handycam HDR-XR500V 120GB Hard Drive HD CamcorderPrice: $829.00
VIXIA HF S100 SDHC Flash Memory HD CamcorderPrice: $759.00
Handycam HDR-XR200V 120GB Hard Drive HD CamcorderPrice: $599.00
- Perfect Printing Solutions Find just the right All-in-One Printer for you from HP. Visit the HP Resource Center.
- Acer Laptop Center Forget the Mouse...check out the next generation multi-gesture touch screen technology from Acer.
- Dell Shopping Center Check out great deals from Dell!
Cameras
Camcorders
Cell Phones
Components
Desktops
HDTV
Home Theater
GPS
Laptops
Monitors
MP3 Players
Networking &
Printers
Storage







