Debate Over ICANN Reform Rages On
Experts agree changes are needed, but don't agree on what those changes should be.
Scarlet Pruitt, IDG News Service
Nearly two months after the president of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers called for fundamental reform of the beleaguered organization, ICANN watchers at the Computers, Freedom, and Privacy conference in San Francisco Thursday continued their high-volume debate over exactly what those reforms should be.
"There's broad consensus that ICANN hasn't worked. We need to ask: Do we need this beast?" said Jerry Berman, executive director of the Center for Democracy and Technology.
Although no one on CFP's ICANN panel suggested scrapping ICANN altogether, all agreed that radical reform is needed. The nonprofit group, which oversees technical issues related to the Internet's addressing system, has been under fire almost since its inception for ineffectiveness and failing to take broad public input into account when making decisions.
Complete Overhaul?
ICANN President Stuart Lynn directly addressed concerns about the organization last February when he called for a complete overhaul of the body. However, Lynn's proposal to bring more government participation and funding to ICANN and eliminate public representation on the board of directors has met with few supporters, leaving the question of how to effectively reform the organization up in the air.
"I think ICANN has been hijacked from within ... from its staff," said Susan Crawford, a partner with the Wilmer, Cutler & Pickering law firm, who has represented registries in the ICANN process.
Crawford suggested that ICANN subcontract some of its responsibilities and become a leaner organization, therefore cutting out the need for heavy reliance on government funding.
"I am hopeful that a humbler, [chastened] ICANN will show up," Crawford said.
Simpler Reforms
ICANN board member Karl Auerbach was not as optimistic.
"We have too much of a shell game going on at ICANN today," said Auerbach, who suggested a reform by which ICANN would be divided into six independent parts--three with governing policy duties and three with governing administrative duties--in order to provide more transparency.
But while all the panelists, and most of the audience, agreed that ICANN is long overdue for reform, there have been no complete proposals put on the table to counter Lynn's, noted Peter G. Neumann, principal scientist with SRI International Computer Science Laboratory.
"What we desperately need is some fleshed-out proposals," Neumann said.
CFP runs through Friday.
Acer Laptop Center
The Best of PC World
- Great year-end deals

for small business! -
Get 24/7 live remote AT&T Tech Support 360* service along with select Lenovo* PCs (with Intel® Core™ 2 Duo processors) and save up to 200!
-
HP EliteBook* 6930p Notebook with Intel® vPro™ technology and a free HP Basic Docking Station - $641 instant savings!
- *Other names and brands may be claimed as the property of others. ©2009 Intel Corporation. Intel, the Intel logo, vPro and Core trademarks of Intel Corporation in the United States and other countries. All rights reserved.
People who read this also read:
Best Prices on Laptops
XPS M1330 Notebook - CustomizablePrice: $599.00
MacBook NotebookPrice: $954.99
Compaq Presario CQ61Z Notebook - CustomizablePrice: $399.99
G71-340US NotebookPrice: $579.98
Pavilion dv4-1540us NotebookPrice: $579.98
Eee PC 1005HA Seashell NetbookPrice: $289.83
- Perfect Printing Solutions Find just the right All-in-One Printer for you from HP. Visit the HP Resource Center.
- Acer Laptop Center Forget the Mouse...check out the next generation multi-gesture touch screen technology from Acer.
- Dell Shopping Center Check out great deals from Dell!
Cameras
Camcorders
Cell Phones
Components
Desktops
HDTV
Home Theater
GPS
Laptops
Monitors
MP3 Players
Networking &
Printers
Storage







