Taiwan Company Sues Apple Over Lost Sales
Luxpro wants compensation for millions it says were lost while its products were under injunction in an Apple lawsuit.
Jeremy Kirk, IDG News Service
A Taiwanese manufacturer is suing Apple for $100 million after a court ruled it could continue producing a portable music player resembling Apple's iPod Shuffle.
Apple sought in July 2005 to stop Luxpro from making its line of Tangent music players, alleging that they too closely resembled the Shuffle. A Taiwan court agreed, but the decision was reversed on appeal.
After the latest ruling, from the Shihlin District Court in Taipei, Luxpro is claiming victory. The company wants compensation for losses it says it incurred when its products were under injunction.
"The motion issued earlier caused Luxpro to lose valuable market opportunities and a considerable amount of orders," Luxpro said on its Web site.
Apple couldn't immediately be reached for comment.
Nearly Identical
The close resemblance of the Tangent to Apple's Shuffle turned more than a few heads at the 2005 Cebit electronics show in Germany where they were introduced.
Luxpro says its products are different because they have a tri-color OLED (organic light emitting diode) monitor and carry its brand name.
The front of the player looks very similar to the Shuffle, however, and they are nearly identical in size.
With HP wireless printers, you could have printed this from any room in the house. Live wirelessly. Print wirelessly.
PCW's Mobile Life Guide
Turn Data into Dollars
Related Tech Industry Articles
- Obama Beats McCain as Spam Target A spam-off shows bulk mailers are far more likely to use Obama's name in the subject line.
- Hotels a Geek Can Love Here are nine geek hotels offering futuristic conveniences and tech amenities at a reasonable rate--sometimes in luxury.
- Vendors, Cops, Profs Team to Study Cybercrime Tech vendors and the Secret Service are among those working with an evaluation of trends and best practices for security.
- Voter Hot Line Upgraded for Election A Web-based Virtual Call Center program will power the Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights Under Law.
- Microsoft Sues DHL After Train Dumps 21,600 Xboxes Microsoft is suing cargo-delivery service DHL Express for allegedly losing 21,600 Xbox game consoles because of a Texas train derailment.
- CDW Security Center Is your data protected? Visit the CDW Security Center Learn where you may be vulnerable and how to address those risks.
- Asus Laptop Showcase Ultra-fashionable thin and light notebooks with SmartLogon Face Recognition. Find out more...
- HP Ink Center Bring improved color and brilliance to your printed material. Visit the Resource Center for more info...








"Taiwan Company Sues Apple Over Lost Sales " Comments