WiFi Finder
Locate wireless services by a specific address, city, state, country, airport, or zip code.
Apple Fails in Attempt to End Burst.com Lawsuit
Jonny Evans, Macworld
With HP wireless printers, you could have printed this from any room in the house. Live wirelessly. Print wirelessly.
Apple met just partial success in persuading court to declare Burst.com's iPod patents invalid.
Apple last night partially failed in its bid to have Burst.com's iPod-focused patent infringement lawsuit thrown out of court.
Burst.com claims that some of its patents for receiving, storing and transmitting audio and video files are at the heart of the iPod.
The company first approached Apple to try to arrange a license for its claimed patents in late 2004. These attempts failed and the company later launched litigation against Apple in April 2006.
Apple has argued that the patents do not rightfully belong to Burst, or that the patents are invalid. Last year Burst settled litigation with Microsoft, which took a licence and paid Burst a US$60 million lump sum.
Apple took that argument to the courts yesterday, seeking a ruling to invalidate parts of four of Burst's patents. U.S. District Judge Marilyn Patel did invalidate some elements of Burst.com's patents, but upheld others, meaning the case must now move on to an out-of-court settlement, appeal or trial.
In a statement on the Burst.com website, the company says: "Judge Marilyn Hall Patel of The United States District Court, Northern California, today issued an order that invalidated as obvious or anticipated 14 claims in the patents in suit between Apple Computer and Burst.com,. The order leaves 22 claims remaining, claims that the court did not find as invalid or anticipated. These remaining 22 claims include some significant audio and video claims that reach key Apple products including the Mac. Burst looks forward to trying its case in court against Apple early next year."
Apple does not comment on ongoing litigation.
For more Macintosh computing news, visit Macworld. Story copyright © 2007 Mac Publishing LLC. All rights reserved.
Laptop Showcase
Office Small Business 2007
Tags at a Glance
Related MP3 Players Articles
- Top 10 MP3 Players (Flash-Based) These are the top flash-based MP3 players today, but ratings and rankings can change quickly due to pricing and technology changes, so check back frequently for the latest info.
- Slacker Portable Internet Radio Player Slacker's portable music player and Web service let you take your favorite music with you and discover similar artists, too.
- Apple Blames Scorching IPods on Battery Problem Apple is blaming a problem with overheating iPods in Japan on faulty batteries.
- Creative Zen X-Fi MP3 Player The amazing Zen X-Fi has better sound, features, headphones, and storage options than the Apple iPod Touch--and for a lower price, too.
- When Apple's Reach Exceeds Its Grasp In the past year, we've seen numerous examples of how Apple's reach can dramatically exceed its grasp.
Camcorders
Handycam HDR-SR11 60GB Hard Drive CamcorderPrice: $854.00
Handycam HDR-SR12 120GB CamcorderPrice: $1008.99
VIXIA HF100 SDHC Flash Memory CamcorderPrice: $623.00
VIXIA HF10 16GB CamcorderPrice: $779.00
VIXIA HV30 Mini DV CamcorderPrice: $718.00
HG10 40GB Hard Drive CamcorderPrice: $615.00
-
CDW Virtualization Center What is Virtualization and how can it help you save money? Click here to find out.
-
Asus Laptop Showcase Ultra-fashionable thin and light notebooks with SmartLogon Face Recognition. Find out more...
-
HP Ink Center Bring improved color and brilliance to your printed material. Visit the Resource Center for more info...
PC World's Marketplace
PC World's Free Whitepapers
"Apple Fails in Attempt to End Burst.com Lawsuit" Comments