Quantcast

NEW Reviews Beta Feedback

  • Print

Sony DCR-IP5 DV Camcorder

thumb 1
  • Sony DCR-IP5

PC World Editor's Review

by Richard Baguley

An extremely portable digital camcorder that unfortunately won't work with most digital video editing software.

The Sony DCR-IP5 is the smallest and lightest camcorder we've seen. But despite its miniscule size, it still has a bright 2.5-inch LCD screen that is easily viewable in all but direct sunlight; it also has battery life comparable with that of the other camcorders we've reviewed, at about an hour. While this unit has no memory card slot, a more expensive version (the DCR-IP7) includes a Memory Stick slot for storing still images and a Bluetooth wireless network adapter.

However, the camcorder's small size does have its disadvantages. It doesn't leave an awful lot of room for the controls, so many of them are extremely small and awkward to use; testers with large hands found the DCR-IP5 a bit difficult to work with, as the controls aren't where the fingers naturally fall. You are also paying a lot for the compact size: At $950, this is the most expensive camcorder we've looked at.

You get a reasonably good selection of features on the camcorder, including composite- and S-Video-in and -out ports and an effective digital image stabilization system. However, the camcorder has no infrared illuminator, though it does provide a slow-shutter mode that tries to make the most of existing light by slowing the shutter speed down.

The DCR-IP5 uses Sony's new MicroMV tape format instead of the more common MiniDV tapes. The Micro MV tapes are much smaller than MiniDV tapes but still hold a full hour of video thanks to the fact that the video is more compressed than it is with MiniDV. The extra compression didn't seem to impact the quality of the recorded video (which looked good, with accurate colors and clear sound). We did notice, however, that the microphone on the top of the case picked up extraneous noises a little too easily.

The downside of MicroMV is that most video editing software can't read in the video. While you can use just about any digital video editing program with any MiniDV camcorder, with MicroMV you are stuck with either Sony's own MovieShaker software (comes with the camcorder) or the extra-cost special version of Pinnacle's Video Studio software that is advertised in the packaging.

UPSHOT: Provides the ultimate in portability, but the fact that you can't use the MicroMV tape format with video editing software other than Sony's own limits the appeal.


SUMMARY
Sony DCR-IP5



10X optical/120X digital zoom lens, 2.5-inch LCD screen, remote control, 3.4 by 3.9 by 1.9 inches, 12 ounces with tape and battery, FireWire-in and -out, composite and S-Video-in and -out. One-year warranty, 24-hour daily tech support.

$950
800/571-7669
www.sonystyle.com

User Reviews for Sony DCR-IP5 DV Camcorder

  • Reviewed by: EricVR4

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: So small you will likely use it more than others (Enough of a reason to buy for some people, maybe even me)

    Weaknesses: video editing, expensive tapes (20 each I think), not so hot support

    Overall Evaluation: It has taken me a while to warm up to this thing. First I kept having to buy tapes because I couldn't figure out how to work with the editing software and just get the files on my computer in a reasonable format, Then when I had more patience I researched and researched some more and figured out how to do it, but then something broke in the camera not allowing the transfer. I must have been in a rare mood because I went through the warranty process and got it fixed (didn't see it for a month). Once you get used to it, it is OK. I read somewhere that you can get "quicktime pro 5" and open and save the files into a different format from there, so you can use whatever editing program you like. Also Movieshaker is a fairly simple program. From there you can import the files into the program and save them in a few different formats. MPEG1 seems to be a decent choice.. and from there you can do what you like with it with other editing programs... or you can just use Movieshaker if you are an editing Newbie like me. Overall the decision to buy should be because of the size.. a miniDV would have tons more support, be cheaper, and easier to use (at least at first).. but the MicroDV is really quite small. PS. I wouldn't trust the bag checkers at the airports.. they say it won't effect camcorders.. but that's when my problem showed up, after going through an airport check.

  • Reviewed by: mstuver

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: Small size.

    Weaknesses: MicroMV format is incompatible with almost all video editing programs.

    Overall Evaluation: I have bought a lot of Sony products over the years so when I was in the market for a camcorder I foolishly just picked this up without researching it. After recording four tapes of my one year old I tried making a DVD and after 20-30 hours and using 3 programs, including Sony's Movieshaker (constant crashes) I have still been unsuccessful. I have just ordered a well reviewed Panasonic camera in DV. MicroMV is a terrible product with zero support from Sony. I won't be buying Sony again.

Similar Products

Camcorders Playing in PCW Video

Latest Camcorders News, Reviews, How-To's

  • Kodak Zi6 Carting a camcorder with you has become a whole lot easier, thanks to pocket-sized digital camcorders such as Pure Digital...
  • Hands-on With the Kodak Zi6 The small digital camera found in pockets and purses across the globe may soon have a companion--the pocket digital camcorder.
  • Sanyo Xacti HD1010 Sanyo's Xacti VPC-HD1010 is a high-definition camcorder that's much smaller than your typical HD model, making it ideal for...
  • September's Coolest Gadgets Roundup of new products that are pushing the limits of technology in cameras, laptops, TVs and more.
  • Sony Unveils Two High-def Camcorders Sony has unveiled a couple of DV-tape based high-def camcorders that will be going on sale in the next couple of months.