Quantcast
PCWorld.com is upgrading some back-end systems. Some site features, such as user registration, may be temporarily unavailable.

NEW Reviews Beta Feedback

  • Print

Konica Minolta DiMAGE A1 SLR Digital Camera (Konica Minolta-2782301)

thumb 1
  • DiMAGE A1 SLR Digital Camera (Konica Minolta-2782301)

Konica Minolta DiMAGE A1 SLR Digital Camera (Konica Minolta-2782301) Review

by Kalpana Ettenson

A flip-up viewfinder and LCD are standout features on this advanced camera.

The $900 DiMage A1 resembles an SLR-camera--it has a big, boxy shape and a large barrel lens. But it has some characteristics that really distinguish it from other advanced cameras. Like a camcorder, the DiMage A1's eye-level viewfinder can be flipped up, so you can adjust it to a comfortable viewing angle. The LCD also can be flipped up and pulled out slightly--a useful feature when taking shots close to the ground. A sensor perceives whether you've put your eye up to the electronic viewfinder, and automatically switches it on and the LCD off, and vice versa.

This advanced camera includes lots of creative controls, including several different flash modes, and the choice of two bracketing settings. Menu choices, however, are poorly organized--there are lots of options, but you have to search through layers of menus to find them.

Most cameras offer a few user-setting modes, but the DiMage A1 allows you to save five user settings so you can quickly access your favorite adjustments. A dedicated dial on the side of the camera lets you save settings easily. The DiMage A1 also has a dedicated button for calibrating white balance--a useful feature when automatic white-balance settings don't work.

Instead of using buttons on the top or back of the camera, you control the zoom lens via a ring on the barrel, just like on a film SLR--which makes adjustments both fast and easy. However, the zoom ring doesn't turn especially smoothly at its widest--and at most telephoto--settings.

The DiMage has a maximum shutter speed of 1/16,000 second; that's considerably faster than most other cameras on our chart. That boosted speed might be useful for taking exceedingly fast action shots, but you'll need a good amount of light or the flash to be able to use it.

As for image quality, the DiMage A1 was a little disappointing, despite its 5-megapixel CCD. Its exposure accuracy was good, but color accuracy and sharpness were below average compared with other advanced cameras. In our outdoor shot, for instance, we saw some speckling in the blue sky; and in our still-life shot, objects didn't look as sharp as they did on shots from other cameras we looked at this month.

Upshot: The DiMage A1 has lots of creative controls that will appeal to an advanced user, but its image quality isn't as strong as that of other advanced cameras.

Kalpana Ettenson

User Reviews for Konica Minolta DiMAGE A1 SLR Digital Camera (Konica Minolta-2782301)

  • Reviewed by: boatboy_srq

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: Excllent array of shooting options; degree of control; manual zoom; impressive anti-shake system; multiple text imprint options.

    Weaknesses: Standard 5MP resolution artifacts in images; proprietary batteries; complex.

    Overall Evaluation: I've been using this camera for two years. So far I can say without reservation that it is a very impressive photographic instrument: it can take bright, sharp, clear images in a variety of settings, and can be made to produce most variations available to standard 35mm photography. I am particularly impressed with the amount and degrees of manual control: virtually any and every variable can be manually specified right down to full manual ISO/shutter speed/aperture/color balance/white balance/focus. The anti-shake tech Minolta used in this camera is also very impressive: it seems to be the most effective of any currently in the marketplace. I can only hope Sony will either incorporate it in its own cameras or sell the tech to Canon, Nikon or Panasonic.The only downsides that I have encountered so far have been the usual downside of 5MP resolution (you can only blow images up so far), the complexity of such a device (which is fairly standard for similar cameras from Canon, Nikon et al), and the use of proprietary tech for batteries and accessories. Anyone who owns these and wants to keep using it ought to stock up on batteries, flash unit, case etc. while these items are still available. Obviously this isn't a dSLR, and doesn't really pretend to be one, so comparisons there are moot: likewise comparisons to 35mm are awkward unless you discuss ISO 400 or 800, where the 5MP CCD actually performs about as well as film for color values and sharpness.Prior posters have commented on the spartan software, minuscule image storage, etc. provided with the A1. Given the trends in digital photography, I found the standard card a hindrance, and I'm actually surprised that anyone buying a camera such as this would not be purchasing a full-featured photo editor (such as Photoshop or PhotoPlus) along with it. Postproduction is often a necessity with digital photographs, and should be anticipated. Likewise, higher resolutions fill up memory very quickly - most professional reviewers recommended increased storage out of the gate for these cameras. I have yet to have my 1GB card filled before the battery needed recharging, and I've been on some marathon shoots hitting over 100 frames per day on a single charge. I do spend some time in postproduction refining the images, but I expect that with digital imaging and liken it to the fine-tuning a good photo shop does with film developing and printing. Often the ideal shot reaches photo paper through the judicious intervention of the lab just as much as through the careful efforts of the shooter. Many users forget that processing is often the difference between ok 35mm shots and exceptional ones, and that part of the advantage of digital photography is that we have the luxury of running our own darkroom after shooting the pictures.

  • Reviewed by: tofman

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: Optics, color rendering, anti-shake, shooting performance and ergonomy. Versatility, battery life. Quality.

    Weaknesses: Images are slightly noisier than competition.Supplied CF card. Takes some time to get the best out of it : The manual is worth to be read.

    Overall Evaluation: The things that made me choose this camera were the image stabilization, versatility of the 28-200 zoom, the shooting performance and ergonomy (don't need to go thru 20 menu to modify an option).Since I got it, I'm still impressed by the overall photo quality, the battery life and the performances of both the included flash as well as the image stabiliser's efficiency.Noise is noticable even at 100ISO, but with a bit of post processing result are simply GREAT. Even 800ISO is still usable (at the cost of more processing and smaller print). 8MP cameras can't go over 400ISO and are much noisier than the A1 at the 800ISO setting. All in all I never faced a situation where I can't find a solution to take the picture with this camera.Another feature worth to be noted : you can program your own presets for a given situation. An internal battery save these settings as well as the clock and can only be replaced by Minolta in the factory. (But without this battery you simply loose these settings but CAN STILL TAKE IMAGES).People are often disapointed with this camera because they often think that buying a great camera will correct their weaknesses as a photograf ; but pictures were never composed by any camera, and are only worth the operator.

People who looked at the Konica Minolta DiMAGE A1 SLR Digital Camera (Konica Minolta-2782301) also looked at:

Latest Cameras Playing in PCW Video

Latest Cameras News, Reviews, How-To's

  • Digital SLR Cameras Buying Guide For serious and professional photographers, Digital Single Lens Reflex (DSLR) cameras are the way to go. They offer faster performance and more flexibility with...
  • Kodak Zi8 Pocket Camcorder Shows Impressive HD Video Quality The full-featured Zi8 captures the best HD pocket-camcorder footage we've seen, but its interface and digital zoom often get in the way.
  • Memorex MCC225 MyVideo Memorex's MCC225 MyVideo HD pocket camcorder records 720p high-definition footage, snaps 5-megapixel still photos, and has a retractable USB connector, like most...
  • Logitech's LifeSize Deal Is a Head-Scratcher Although computer peripherals and telepresence are an unlikely pairing, the acquisition puts Logitech in competition with Cisco, HP, Polycom and others.
  • Holiday Camera Gift Guide Whether you're shopping for a socialite, an advanced photographer, a YouTube star, or your crazy uncle, you'll find the perfect camera here.