
Motorola Q Cell Phone

Pricing
$138.99 - $139.95 From 2 Vendors Get Best Prices »
- Lab Tested
- How We Test Phones »
Pros
Impressive slimline design
Inexpensive for a PDA/phone
Cons
Doesn't include Office apps
Navigation controls are hard to use
Bottom Line
This slim, stylish Windows Mobile smart phone is inexpensive, but it needs extra cost software to edit Office documents.
Motorola Q
Q Cell Phone Review, by Melissa J. Perenson July 26, 2006
Like the Razr before it, the Motorola Q clearly aims to make a fashion--and technophile--statement. Slim and stylish, this silver-hued PDA/phone is just 11.5mm thick--thinner than the Razr, and significantly more compact than competing smart phones from HP, Palm, Research in Motion, and T-Mobile,. Unfortunately, the unit lacks some of the features found on the competition, such as a selection of office productivity apps.
The Q is available from Verizon Wireless for $300 with a two-year contract (as of 7/7/06); in the land of PDA phones, that's a bargain. But that low price comes with some trade-offs. In particular, I found the limitations of the Windows Mobile operating system (the same problems that I and others have experienced with the T-Mobile SDA, for example) constraining. These constraints are more noticeable on the Q than they are on the SDA (which we categorize as a standard cell phone), perhaps because I wanted this PDA/phone to be more capable out of the box--more like the Treo 700w, for example. The Q's bundled software includes only a document viewer, so you'll need to purchase another application if you want to edit office documents. It also lacks a notepad.
With the design of the Windows Mobile 5-based Q, Motorola seems to be attempting to create a new hybrid that draws on the best elements of the latest smart phones from Palm (maker of the Treo 700 series) and RIM (maker of the BlackBerry 8700 series). On the upper-right corner of the phone, a BlackBerry-like click wheel let's you scroll through content. The device also has a five-way navigational control, a QWERTY keyboard, and six menu navigation buttons in the center, just like the Palm Treo series. The menu navigation buttons here are pressure-sensitive and soft, however--a design touch reminiscent of, though not identical to, the flat buttons on the Razr.
As appealing as I found the overall look of the Q--and as impressed as I am with what this phone packs inside its streamlined chassis--I was disappointed by its design in several respects. The keyboard's lack of a backspace button among the QWERTY keys proved problematic. I also found the click wheel a bit stiff, and the soft-key panel surprisingly tough for my fingers to navigate--in part because of the unit's width (it's wider than the more palm-friendly Palm Treo 700). Given the unit's lack of a touch screen, how your hand responds to the feel of the buttons will determine how much you enjoy using the Q.
Another gripe concerns the position of the mini-USB port. I know I've often used a cell phone while it's tethered to an outlet charging. However, Motorola locates the mini-USB port--which doubles as the power port--in an awkward position on the lower left of the Q. This is inconvenient if you try to use the device in your hands--either for reading content, or putting it up to your ear.
Some things I really liked: I found the keyboard, with its slanted, oblong keys, roomy compared to the Treo's, and easier to handle than the keyboard on the much-wider BlackBerry 8700 series. The Q has a bright, clear QVGA 320-by-240-resolution display, a miniSD Card slot on the side, and a top-mounted headphone jack. The unit's 1.3-megapixel digital camera has a reasonably effective 6X digital zoom. The camera has a dedicated access button (lower row of the keyboard, along with dedicated email and speakerphone buttons), but I found saving and changing functions within the camera mode unintuitive. For example, the image preview only occupies the middle section of the roomy screen.
In day-to-day use, I had mixed feelings about the Q. The unit takes longer to start up than I liked, though it wasn't any worse than T-Mobile SDA. Ostensibly you can use the unit with one hand, but I found the unit much better suited to two-handed operation.
Despite access to Verizon's high-speed EvDO wireless network, the Q seemed sluggish on the Internet. In our lab tests, the Q's talk-time battery life scored only Fair, lasting 5 hours and 38 minutes--better than battery life of the Treo 700p and 700w, but worse than on most PDA/phones we've tested recently.
If you need a slimline, large-screened companion at a comparatively low price, the Q deserves consideration. But if looks and size aren't paramount, it may be worth the extra bucks to step up to another device, and gain more functionality.
Melissa J. Perenson
0 Comments | 0 Topics | Print Only This Review
- Rating Breakdown
-
65
-
87
-
82
- See Complete Lab Results »
Performance Comparison with Similar Phones
65
76
95
100
Performance
| Battery Life Average (hh:mm) | 5:38 |
| Battery Life Word Score | Fair |
Average User Reviews for Motorola Q Cell Phone
- Latest User Reviews 4 reviews
-
Reviewed by: joey301
Duration of ownership: 2 Weeks
Strengths: Nice Features. Easy to use. Bluetooth works very well. Speech dialing very easy to use
Weaknesses: Slow to start up. Synchronizes only with Outlook out of the box. Verizons data plans are too expensive. No FM radio
Overall: I have really enjoyed mine so far. I returned the Chocolate for this one. I like being able to add my own music and listen to it from the mono bluetooth instead of being restricted to stereo like the Chocolate. I use if for listening to podcasts on the ride to work and it is easy to transfer mp3 files. I wish Verizon offered a phone with FM. The Nokias and the Sony often have them, but none of Verizon's phones has it. I would also be happy if I could afford Verizon's data plan, but a minimum of $80 a month is just too much for the casual user. I have not found a way yet for the phone to monitor bytes used, so the 10mb plan is out of the question . The only other thing I have noticed is the area of the phone where some of the buttons are located in the front. I think one could too easily pull that top layer of plastic off just above the enter key. However, I think that overall the quality of the hardware is very high. Joey
-
Reviewed by: averase
Duration of ownership: 1 Month
Strengths: Thin, light easy to use interface
Weaknesses: Must purchase a data plan, but Verizon doesn't tell you that before you buy. Had to replace the phone twice. Battery life is a joke. No Office applications. Can view, but not edit, Office documents. Never did pair it with a Belkin Bluetooth adapter.
Overall: It isn't so much the phone, but Verizon's backhanded sales gotchas. I had the phone for a month before I got a bill from Verizon. They had piled up $350 dollars in data services, which I never used. The phone was "phoning home" to update applications without my permission. In the process of trying to resolve this bill, I was told, "You should never have been sold this phone without a data services contract." Duh. Ya think? Why is this even necessary? Could they never have envisioned someone who just might want a combo phone and PDA? As to the phone. I had to replace it twice before I got one that worked. The battery that comes with the phone is exhausted in eight hours tops. The extended life battery lasts about sixteen hours without a recharge. The extended life battery ruins the thin design. The lack of support for Office applications is a turn-off. You can get a document viewer, you can even use this phone to do presentations, but you have to edit on your PC. The sound is adequate and loading music is a piece of cake, but you'd do better with a KRAZR if whate you want is music. I know. I traded in this dog for a KRAZR, not that using the KRAZR is easy, but that's another story. The phone isn't a very adept PDA, so next purchase is - A PDA. Verizon's hidden charges and the phone calling home all day are the big problems as I see it. If what you are looking for is a phone get a phone. If what you want is a PDA, get a PDA. This phone just isn't capable.
-
Reviewed by: fillossofer
Duration of ownership: 2 Months
Strengths: Size, functionality, clear & bright screen
Weaknesses: Locks up too frequently, battery life
Overall: bluetooth headset. Haven't been impressed with the speed of EVDO when surfing web, but downloads seem to come across fast. I got the extended battery from Verizon for $20 (they must have had so many complaints to be giving it away at that price - or it is made by Sony, one of the two). With that I easily make it through the day on one charge. I haven't been able to pair the device with Windows Media Player. From what I've read of the latest upgrade, I'll be expecting another very soon. I need better reliability from my mobile phone than what the Q currently offers.
-
Reviewed by: jbjtkbw00
Duration of ownership: 2 Months
Strengths: Only $199 with a 2yr New Line of Service Extended battery INCLUDED in my purchase Outstanding multimedia capabilities Excellent Bluetooth Performance
Weaknesses: No document editor Extended battery ruins thin form factor
Overall: I went from a Palm Visor Prism --> Palm Tungsten C --> Treo 650 --> PPC6700 --> Motorola Q. Other than the lack of wi-fi and a document editor, I truly think this is the best pda/phone I've ever owned. It fits in the pocket very easily and as long as you lock your keypad, it will even go into a back pocket with no effort at all. The keys are a lot roomier than a Treo, yet you can still perform all functions with 1 hand unlike the PPC6700. Screen size is nice and wide and very bright. Everything about the form factor makes it a nice fit and comfortable to hold onto. I really enjoy navigation on this and the operation is fairly smooth and effortless, however it does seem to delay in moving from screen to screen and some programs do take a while to open. I see my longest delay with Handmark's Pocket Express, but it could also be the size of the program itself. Also, like most Windows Mobile 5 smartphones/pdas, you have a constant need to shut down programs that continue to run. This is the main reason I only give this device a 4 star rating. Other than these few petty annoyances, operation is really simple. Multimedia stands out on this phone. The device has 2 stereo speakers on the back and while this is a poor design flaw if you want to sit this phone on your desk, once propped up or in a holster, these speakers are quite loud! They also sound really good. I've watched movies and listened to mp3's and the stereo sound was phenomenal. I've paired them with the Motorola Bluetooth stereo headset and the sound is even better. Finally, this phone allows you to play back most files and creating ringtones can be done using just regular mp3's. How convenient! All in all, I've had great luck with this phone and it's been quite the conversation starter. I haven't seen another phone that I've really liked other than this and it'll be interesting to see how this phone performs on the the Sprint-Nextel network when released in Q4.
Review Now! Already own it? Tell us What You Think
-
Reviewed by: someone01
Strengths: tough
Weaknesses: battery, camera, slow OS
Overall: It has been durable withstanding a few drops. Unfortunately going to a phone without a touchscreen makes slow to browse and change programs. Response times also lag, such as waiting for screen changes. You also have to buy a larger battery to make it last though the day which then puts a bulge on the back making it much thicker. I also miss the ability to security lock documents without locking the whole phone.
-
Reviewed by: esarabia
Strengths: syncs very easily to all your contacts, emails, task, calendar, etc... Windows based OS allows you to run multiple applications very quickly. Thin in comparison to other smartphones
Weaknesses: qwerty styled keypad can give you issues, people with bigger fingers can push wrong button easily
Overall: I have used this phone for some time now and I love it. I had to carry a phone and a pda and now I have them both. It isn't perfect, but for my needs and budget, it is the best decision I could've made.
-
Reviewed by: xip4
Strengths: Thin and stylish
Weaknesses: a lot of softwares designed for windows mobile 5 can not be installed in Motorola Q
Overall: The quaility of the Built in camera is not good, although it has a built in flash. However, the sound is satisfied when you play the MP3 music. You can only set one alarm. And the LCD is beatiful and big enough to watch movies.
-
Reviewed by: PainGain
Strengths: Thin, Light, QWERTY Keyboard, Nice Screen, Attractive Design, MiniSD Slot
Weaknesses: Retail Price (Though Deals can be had, if signing long contract)
Overall: This is my first "Smart Phone" and I am very glad that took the jump. This phone is thin and light. Though a bit wide, the width is necessary for its functionality. So, overall, it's a great size.I have heard complaints about the battery, but so far, it seems to last me 1-2 days. However, I would suggest purchasing another battery for worry free use.The screen is large and sharp looking. It does smudge easily and has a glare in most lighting. If you dont like completely covering your phone in a skin, I would suggest purchasing a screen protector that just sticks onto the screen. It keeps it smudge free, limits the glare, and will give peace of mind from scratching your beautiful display.The Motorola Q has so many features to list in my review. However, its media capabilities are endless (especially when having an added 2gb MiniSD installed. Email, Web Surfing, Playing Games, Taking Pictures, Working on Documents, etc etc. Great Phone. Definitely look into getting a data/web plan through your wireless carrier if you are planning on getting this phone. That's where the true power is with the Q.
-
Reviewed by: mopefree
Strengths: easy to handle, crystal clear screen
Weaknesses: bluetooth not so clear, did not come with miniSD card
Overall: At first glance, this phone is clumsy big. However, after using it for a week, I found it convenient to operate. You can choose different display layout and wallpaper. My plan also comes with unlimited internet access. It is like using a mobile computer. Awesome!

| Merchant | Price | Merchant Rating |
|---|---|---|
| PCTechSystems, Inc. | $138.99 Buy Now » | |
| brilliantones | $139.95 Buy Now » |
Phones similar to the Motorola Q Cell Phone
We recommend these Phones for their similarities to the Motorola Q Cell Phone in features, specs, ratings, and user interest.
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
- Before you buy
- How to Buy a Cellphone
- Related Charts
- Top 10 Cell Phones
- Top 10 Unlocked Cell Phones

Pricing
$138.99 - $139.95 From 2 Vendors Get Best Prices »
Start New Topic Don't see the answer to your question? Ask it here!
Cameras
Camcorders
Cell Phones
Components
Desktops
HDTV
Home Theater
GPS
Laptops
Monitors
MP3 Players
Networking &
Printers
Storage
Facebook









