Adobe Photoshop CS3 is brimming with so many image-editing tools that the biggest challenge facing it seems to be where to stuff them all. This latest version of Photoshop adds even more tools and enhancements to the mix, but it cleans up its act with a simple yet effective approach to palette organization.
Adobe Adobe Photoshop CS3
Pros
Palettes toolbar saves screen space
Refine Edge tool makes pro selections
Cons
Quick Selection tool has some issues
Pricey
Adobe Photoshop CS3
Adobe Photoshop CS3 Review, by Alan Stafford March 26, 2007
I tried out the software in beta form; this is the first time Adobe has offered the public a nonfinal version of its image editing program. (Existing Photoshop CS2 users can download the free trial version.) Photoshop CS3, which will be Microsoft Windows Vista-compatible, will anchor Adobe's full Creative Suite, expected later this year. On its own, the shipping version will sell for $649.
Many Photoshop users opt for dual-monitor setups just so they'll have a place to stow the application's seemingly endless array of screen-hogging palettes. Photoshop CS3, however, introduces an important interface upgrade: resizable palette buttons with fly-out capabilities.
Both single-monitor and dual-monitor users can benefit from this upgrade. You can reduce the buttons to tiny size, or you can tear off the palettes and park them around your screen, as with previous Photoshop versions. A third option is to arrange them in one or two columns and choose only the palettes you want. At their smallest, the buttons are narrower than the tools palette (which also got a minor makeover--now you can resize it to be one column or two, as well).
The redesigned setup makes using those palettes easier, too. For example, to switch layers, just click the palette's tiny icon, and the full palette pops open. Click the layer you want and then click back to your image, and the palette automatically closes. Other Adobe apps already have similar fly-outs; they're long overdue in the company's flagship application.
With Photoshop CS3's new Quick Selection tool, choosing the portions of your image to act on is simpler, too. With this tool, you don't have to hold down the Shift key to add to your selection; instead, click the areas of your image that you want to select, and you're done (perfect for making a complicated selection while holding a cold beverage in your off-mouse hand).
I found that the tool works very well with sharp, high-contrast color images, where it functions as a smarter, faster magic wand tool. But unlike the magic wand, the Quick Selection tool (at least in beta form) lacks a tolerance setting, and as a result it often selected the entire image after a few clicks.
I was more impressed with Photoshop CS3's new Refine Edge tool. After making a selection, you can adjust its radius, contrast, and smoothness by using the tool's sliders. Refine Edge is great for clearing away rough edges and extraneous pixels, even if you do take the trouble to create pixel-level selections.
CS3's Auto-Align Layers let you combine multiple images (which you arrange as separate layers in the same file). The tool matches up common elements in the images; then you can use other tools to choose portions of whichever image you want. So if Bob's got his peepers open in one and closed in another, you can bring forth his baby blues instead of his eyelids. This function works best with pictures taken in rapid succession by a digital SLR mounted on a tripod.
Adobe's Camera Raw utility gets beefed up, too--so much so that you may spend less time in the main Photoshop window than in the Raw one. The final version will even have the main application's spot-healing brush, though the beta lacks it.
Every year, Photoshop gets better tools. But this year, the refinement I liked most is the new palette treatment. Tools work better when you have room to use them.
Alan Stafford
0 Comments | 0 Topics | Print Only This Review
Average User Reviews for Adobe Adobe Photoshop CS3
- Latest User Reviews 1 review
-
Reviewed by: Lengo
Duration of ownership: 14 Months
Strengths: New layer types that allow for easy re-editing.
Weaknesses: No change from Photoshop 6 on some of the existing features, and downgraded brush tool from Photoshop 6. The render/lighting tool still has not made available the entire pane for placing the lights. The brush tool in PS 6 used to have all widgets on one panel - size, softness, roundness, and angle, but now you need two panels to get to this. And still, after three upgrades that cost me over $450, there are inconsistencies in the tools -- none act the same as the others (you can dial in numbers on some tools, but you can't on others). And lastly, the masking tools are a joke, especially the Quick Mask (which should be named Pain-in-the-Ass Masking tool). It seems that Adobe's game plan is to keep this product not quite right so that they can keep selling it to people that hope that the next generation will fix the problems. Instead of fixing them, Adobe offers new features. I don't need new features. I need what's in PS 3 fixed so that my productivity increases.
Overall: This product is way overpriced. Upgrades don't deliver advantages to the user interface after 3 (count 'em) generations of this software. New features are great, but inconsistencies in how they work make productivity low, and the product can STILL be improved, but I'm not buying another generation of Photoshop on the hopes that they finally got it right. Not for another $160+! Oh! And uh... where is the monitor calibration tool that came with PS 6? It is gone!
Review Now! Already own it? Tell us What You Think
Sorry, the product you requested isn't currently available from any of our sellers.
Multimedia similar to the Adobe Adobe Photoshop CS3
We recommend these Multimedia for their similarities to the Adobe Adobe Photoshop CS3 in features, specs, ratings, and user interest.
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
|
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
![]() |
|
Latest Prices » |
- Related Charts
- Web-Based Photo Editors
Start New Topic Don't see the answer to your question? Ask it here!
Lenovo Laptop Deals
-
ThinkPad Edge A welcome refresh of Lenovo's workhorse line that improves look and feel without sacrificing the features that make ThinkPads so well-loved.
-
ThinkPad T400 Performance meets portability in T400's lightweight design, switchable graphics and superior power management.
Cameras
Camcorders
Cell Phones
Components
Desktops
HDTV
Home Theater
GPS
Laptops
Monitors
MP3 Players
Networking &
Printers
Storage
Facebook








