Quantcast
PCWorld.com is upgrading some back-end systems. Some site features, such as user registration, may be temporarily unavailable.

NEW Reviews Beta Feedback

  • Print

Data Robotics Data Robotics Drobo

84

Very Good

  • Pros
  • Sleek design
  • Easy expansion
  • Cons
  • Rebuilding a drive takes time
thumb 1 thumb 2 thumb 3 thumb 4

Data Robotics Data Robotics Drobo Review

by Melissa J. Perenson

The slick design and easy setup of Drobo make this USB appliance a strong choice for expanding your system's storage.

Data Robotics' new Drobo is designed to safeguard your data automatically. The company's innovative approach to data handling distinguishes Drobo from the sea of multidrive external enclosures currently available, and Drobo's ease of use and flexibility make it a great fit for environments that lack a dedicated IT person to decipher the complexities of typical RAID storage options.

Drobo is a direct-attached USB 2.0 storage appliance for PC and Mac that sells for $499. The streamlined, attractive device is a bring-your-own-hard-drive affair: The price includes only the chassis, which has four empty Serial ATA drive bays that can handle drives with capacities of up to 1 terabyte each. This actually adds to Drobo's appeal, since its storage capacity can grow to suit your needs. (See the company's site for a look at how you can mix and match hard-drive capacities.)

Unlike RAID 5-based systems, which often require you to tweak settings, Drobo needs no adjustments: The unit employs its own disk and storage virtualization algorithms to provide automatic data redundancy. The device gives users many of the benefits of RAID 5 without the complexity of such a multidrive setup. With its own operating system, CPU, and memory to power data-handling smarts, the appliance allows you to swap a drive out, even as you continue working on files stored on the system. In contrast, a multidrive RAID 5 system would require you to rebuild the RAID before you could start accessing data again.

Drobo knows where each of block of data is stored on a disk, and its algorithms are more flexible than the RAID standards in wide use today. Together, these factors make it easier for the user to manage the data device as one large "pool" of data, and for Drobo to monitor itself for data corruption and disk failure. Other differences between RAID 5 and Drobo: RAID 5 requires three or more drives, with the available capacity defaulting to the lowest-common-denominator capacity among the drives, while Drobo offers a similar level of redundancy across two to four drives; and RAID 5 uses parity, ignoring available space on a disk, while Drobo's storage virtualization can intelligently make use of free space across any of the unit's drives. One warning: While Drobo offers the data redundancy necessary to protect you against hardware failure, it won't protect against theft or catastrophic disaster. You may still want to keep a second copy of your data elsewhere, as a true backup.

In my hands-on time with Drobo, I found the unit exceptionally friendly and easy to use. When you open the box, a three-step setup poster walks you through the basics: Insert the drives, attach the power cable and USB 2.0 cable, and install the software. The user manual, inspiring in its clarity and its approachable layout, helps explain things nicely.

To get started, I slipped in four test drives of varying sizes: 80GB, 160GB, 400GB, and 500GB. Together the drives yielded 593GB of total available storage, out of the total 1140GB in the device. Adding a drive was simply a matter of pushing it into the available space until it clicked; removing drives was simple, too, thanks to the unit's easy-glide lever.

I then powered up Drobo and attached it to my Windows Vista Professional system, which recognized it as a USB mass-storage device, no host software required. The installation of the Drobo Dashboard software went smoothly, too. This no-frills program identifies which drives are in which bays, provides a capacity chart, offers some utilities, and gives you a way to monitor the device beyond the status lights to the right of each drive. The lights use a simple, color-coded approach to informing you of Drobo's status--or more precisely, of the health of each individual drive inside Drobo. If the status lights are green, your data is safe. If the lights turn orange, Drobo is at 85 percent capacity, and you must replace a drive with a larger one. Red lights indicate that your data is not being automatically protected, and that you should add or replace a drive immediately. Data Robotics says that Drobo interacts with the Self-Monitoring and Analysis Reporting Technology (SMART) capabilities integrated on many hard drives, and that the system will proactively report a drive it senses is failing.

The unit ran cool to the touch, and was quiet, too. Data transfer speeds were middle of the road--not as fast as I'd expect from a USB-attached drive, but passable. Drobo isn't about speed, however. You should choose this device if you want an easy way to put extra storage on your desk--or on that of one of your departments--without the IT resources needed to support a RAID 5 system.

Melissa J. Perenson

User Reviews for Data Robotics Data Robotics Drobo

  • Reviewed by: scrybe

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: Simple, easy redundant back-ups.

    Weaknesses: None so far...

    Overall Evaluation: I just purchased my Drobo from buyDig.com for $344 (free shipping!) I love this thing! I'd been eyeing it for a little over a year! But I was skeptical. I read a lot of criticisms and praises trying to feel it out. Once the price dropped below $350, I had to buy one. Gotta say, it's everything it's advertised to be. I bought two 500 GB Hitachi HDDs from New Egg, final damage there $171.50, including $29.98 replacement plan ($14.99 each). Loaded them in, loaded the software, attached the power cord and USB connection and after a painless firmware upgrade I was moving all my files off my external hard drives onto this puppy! Nice...fast...painless. Try doing that with any RAID Array! My files are secure! I plan on upgrading to 4TBs (2.5TBS usable space) in the coming months. In the passed I've manually backed up my important data. Like many other reviewers I'm a PC hobbyist with no technical knowledge of managing RAID arrays. Drobo keeps me informed and my data safe. That means a lot considering I recently had two Lacie 500 GB hard drives (the ones with fans) die on me. Both purchased in March 2007 (under warranty). If I can get Lacie to fork over replacements, I'll sell the new drives to buy 2 500 Gb hard drives for my Drobo. I'll update this review with any issues I encounter. 09/08/09 UPDATE: Still going strong with no issues to report! In the passed year I've upgraded from 4 500 Gb HDDs to 4 1TB drives with no problem.

  • Reviewed by: Mason Storm

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: Completely free to add and change drives at any time without having to deal with RAID issues. Protects your data at all times. A first of its kind in many ways.

    Weaknesses: Slow USB2 connection - often too slow to stream an HD movie (unbearable stuttering); expensive; VERY noisy if you have 4 HDDs in it.

    Overall Evaluation: This unit is very user friendly; I haven't been able to find any other NAS/DAS solution that allows the end user to freely change drives at any time (one at a time, anyway), without having to worry about RAID issues that can get so confusing with other arrays. It automatically backs up your data so that if a drive fails, you won't lose a thing (which naturally means you sacrifice considerable drive capacity to provide for that backup). It looks good and, so long as you don't actually fill it up with 4 HDDs, is nearly silent. If you DO put 4 HDDs in it, it has to spin its fan on high most of the time to keep the heat level under control - and that makes it VERY VERY noisy. (If you kept it on your desk when you only had 3 HDDs in it, you'll want to move it into another room when you add a 4th.) It's quite expensive for what it does (although it's truly the first of its kind in more than one way), and it's very very slow compared to other NAS solutions (it's unclear why Data Robotics would choose USB2 over eSATA, and doubtlessly, they will soon implement a revision that uses eSATA). But at an even deeper level, its mini-computer self is just too slow to stream HD movies much of the time, and it stutters unacceptably (I was downright embarrassed hosting get-togethers where others viewed movies streamed by this turtle). For NAS use, most users will also need to buy their DroboShare unit (unless you own a router that allows a USB device to be networked). Lastly, Windows itself will always erroneously report that you have a 2TB drive, no matter how much you've actually put in there; you do have to use their Dashboard software to have access to reliable size information about the array. (There is a hack for XP users that fixes the issue, but not for Vista.)

People who looked at the Data Robotics Data Robotics Drobo also looked at:

Latest Hard Drives Playing in PCW Video

Latest Hard Drives News, Reviews, How-To's

Products that match 'Data Robotics Data Robotics Drobo'