Quantcast
PCWorld.com is upgrading some back-end systems. Some site features, such as user registration, may be temporarily unavailable.

NEW Reviews Beta Feedback

  • Print

Sharp BD-HP20U

80

Very Good

  • Pros
  • Top-notch picture and audio quality
  • Turns on practically immediately
  • Cons
  • No Divx support
thumb 1 thumb 2 thumb 3

Sharp BD-HP20U Review

by Lincoln Spector

This Blu-ray player delivers video that looks and sounds great.

Sharp's first Blu-ray Disc player, the BD-HP20U ($550 as of 4/24/08), is a winner on all counts.

Turn on the BD-HP20U and the unit is powered up and ready to receive a disc in under 6 seconds. That's less than a third of the time that any other player I tested took for that chore.

True, once on, it's slower than many others at starting to play, but the combined startup time of 41 seconds was still faster than any other player, and almost twice as fast as the Pioneer Elite BDP-95FD.

But it's what you see (and hear) when you have it going that counts. The Sharp simply surpassed every other player on almost all criteria. Our jury rated it number one in our tests of detail, color quality, brightness and contrast, and audio.

Aside from a great picture, great sound, and a fast response time, the BD-HP20U doesn't offer much. It lacks an ethernet port, Divx support (common on competing Blu-ray Disc players), and picture-in-picture BonusView support. Even the included USB port is limited--it can be used only for firmware updates, not for running images or media files.

This model does have an on-board capability to decode Dolby TrueHD and Dolby Digital Plus audio--a boon for titles that come with those sound-track formats.

One downside to the player's design: If you lose the remote, you're in trouble. The sole buttons on the front panel are Power and Open/Close.

The unit's chassis design isn't the only flaw in the BD-HP20U. The on-screen menus lack consistency: At times they're easy to read, with large type and icons, and at other times they're text-heavy with a font that looks like a typewriter with worn-out ribbon. On the positive side, they explain the options.

But that's complaining about small stuff. Where it really counts, this is one great Blu-ray Disc player.

--Lincoln Spector

User Reviews for Sharp BD-HP20U

  • Reviewed by: am_offline

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: Great Video and Upconversion

    Weaknesses: Does not play all BluRay disc, firmware upgrades needed, slow start up...

    Overall Evaluation: This is a great BluRay player when and if it works. Often discs will not play and you get "Incompatible Disc", even though they are. You may get lucky by reloading the disc until it plays. Sometimes midway through your movie, it starts to pause the play back or stop playing altogether. The solution is to upgrade the firmware, however if you are on a MAC you are hosed. Why? Well you need to put the update from the Sharp Website on a USB drive, and the drive cannot have anything on it except the update. If you are on a MAC, the MAC will put extra hidden folder data on the USB, so it won't work, it needs to be done with a PC. They should have put the USB port in the front and not the back because it is a pain to get to. I don't know how non-tech savy people survive with this thing.Another issue is that often standard DVD functions, menus, skip, top menu will not work on this player (work fine on other players) and the loading of BluRay and SD DVD can be really slow. Buy this is you own a PC, have a spare empty USB drive, have lots of patience, and are tech savvy enough to know how to find the software update on the Sharp Website, download it to your PC, unzip the firmware update, put that on your USB USB drive, unzip the update, then plug it in to the player and make the update.

  • Reviewed by: haleska

    Duration of ownership:

    Strengths: High quality audio and video out. Speaker settings function a real plus. Ease of initial set-up. Latest firmware easy to install. Ability to up-convert DVDs is excellent

    Weaknesses: Initial disk read is slow before play can start

    Overall Evaluation: I already had a Sharp 46" LCD HD Aquos TV which was only missing a HD input from a movie source. When Blu-ray finally won its war, it was time to buy Blu-ray player, and why not from same company as the LCD TV manufacturer. Suggestions - make the front panel play-back progess display larger and tone down the shiny front panel

People who looked at the Sharp BD-HP20U also looked at:

Latest Blu-Ray News, Reviews, How-To's