Quantcast
PCWorld.com is upgrading some back-end systems. Some site features, such as user registration, may be temporarily unavailable.

« Return to: Search Engine Shoot-Out

Text-Search Blanket Finish
In our tests, variation among the top four general Web search engines was minor, with Microsoft's Live Search coming in a distant fifth; Ask.com finished two points behind Live Search and ranked in sixth place.
Service First round Second round Third round Average Comments
AlltheWeb 10 of 10 24 24 24 This Yahoo-owned site blends its parent's powerful search index with a homely but easy-to-use interface.
AltaVista 10 of 10 22 23 23 Another Yahoo property that's a top-notch text-searcher. The spartan interface is more aesthetically appealing than AlltheWeb's.
Google Search 9 of 10 21 20 21 The goliath of Web search, Google still manages to be comprehensive, timely, and a breeze to use.
Yahoo Search 9 of 10 20 21 21 Great engine, but Yahoo's overwrought home page is the Vegas Strip of search sites. (The Yahoo engine also powers AlltheWeb and AltaVista.)
Microsoft Live Search 8 of 10 16 16 16 A notch below Google and Yahoo, yet a solid engine. But it isn't well integrated with other Live services the way Google and Yahoo services mesh.
Ask.com 5 of 10 14 - 14 A decent showing, but some results weren't as timely or as accurate as those from competing sites. Its experimental Act X interface shows promise.
LookSmart 5 of 10 - - - -
Gigablast 2 of 10 - - - -
Open Directory Project 1 of 10 - - - -
Wikipedia 1 of 10 - - - -
Chart note: The average score is composed of scores from three rounds of testing. In the first round we posed ten queries, awarding one point if a link to the target response--or the response itself--was included in the first page of results. In the second and third rounds, we awarded three points when the target response was available from the first result (or above it, in several cases), two points if the target was in the second or third result, and one point if the response was listed elsewhere on the first page of results.