Could Squashing Piracy Boost Economies?

WASHINGTON -- A ten-point drop in the estimated 35 percent global software piracy rate would create 2.4 million jobs and $400 billion in economic growth over four years, according to a study released by a software trade group Thursday.

Countries such as China and Russia, where piracy rates hover around 90 percent, would receive huge economic benefits from reducing the unauthorized use of software, said the Business Software Alliance (BSA). China could triple its tech economy and create 1.8 million new IT jobs in four years, with a ten-point drop in its estimated 90 percent piracy rate, said the study, conducted by IT industry analysis firm IDC.

U.S. software vendors would benefit from piracy reductions in the rest of the world, said Robert Holleyman, BSA president and CEO. But every $1 spent of software in a country generates more money for software services and channel partners such as retailers and resellers, and most businesses providing services or selling in the channel are local, he said.

"The majority of those benefits remain in-country," Holleyman said.

The study of the benefits of reducing piracy in 70 countries has a slight change in focus from past BSA/IDC research. Previous studies have focused on the costs of piracy, and one released in May said the losses from piracy totaled $33 billion in 2004 and $29 billion in 2003.

Making Efforts

Representatives of the Russian and Chinese embassies in Washington, D.C., weren't immediately available for comment on the newest study. However, earlier this year, the Chinese government committed to ending the use of unauthorized software by government agencies by the end of 2005. In May, embassy representative Chu Maoming said the Chinese government investigated more than 9000 cases of intellectual property rights infringement in 2004.

"China has been doing a lot of work in fighting against IPR violations," Maoming said in May.

China has not updated the U.S. government on its progress toward ending government software piracy, said Chris Israel, international intellectual property rights enforcement coordinator at the U.S. Department of Commerce.

"We believe some progress has been made, but that's a very big goal," Israel said at a BSA press conference. "We have very high expectations that those commitments are met."

There's a "growing recognition" among many government leaders worldwide that their economies will benefit from strong intellectual property protections, Israel added. "You simply cannot have a sophisticated knowledge-based economy if you do not protect intellectual property," he said.

Asked if ten-point reductions in the percentage of pirated software are achievable, Holleyman pointed to several past examples in the study, including large percentage drops in Italy and Taiwan after those governments stepped up enforcement. "It's imminently achievable," he said.

Other Views

Not everyone in the tech industry agrees such conclusions regarding cutting piracy. Free Software advocate Karsten M. Self, a programmer and network administrator, keeps an old essay critiquing a piracy study from the late '90s on his personal Web site.

Self argues piracy could have a number of benefits that are difficult to measure, such as keeping the cost of licensed software down.

"There's the question of whether or not piracy is good or bad, for both the software companies and society," Self wrote. "What we need is a cost-benefit analysis of this situation ... Presumably, each pirate copy represents some productivity gain for the person using it. I don't know how to quantify the market efficiency loss, and I don't know that it goes beyond the real ... lost revenues of the software company."

The BSA's Holleyman argued that consumers, as well as businesses and governments, would reap the economic benefits of reduced piracy.

According to the study, a ten-point drop would:

  • Generate $67 billion in worldwide tax revenues in four years.
  • Triple the size of Russia's IT sector from $9.2 billion today to $30 billion in four years.
  • Boost the U.S. economy by $125 billion in four years. The U.S. has the world's lowest rate of software piracy at 21 percent, according to BSA.
  • Add add $19 billion to the U.K. economy in four years.
To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
Related:
  
Shop Tech Products at Amazon