Nokia Booklet 3G To Sell For $299 - Is It A Deal?

AT&T and Nokia will offer the new Booklet 3G wireless netbook for only $299. Is that a good deal? It depends.

First, the actual price of the Booklet 3G is $599. To get the discount, customers have to sign-up for a $60-a-month data plan. Over the two-year contract, that adds up to over $1,400, plus the computer and taxes.

For less money, you can get a wireless 3G card that can be moved from one computer to another. Or a Novatel Wireless MiFi 2200 mobile hotspot modem that allows several computers to share the same 3G connection.

Both of those are better deals, at least for many people, than a netbook, even a nice one like the Booklet 3G. (Nokia said it expects to sell 20 million of them before the end of 2009).

Besides 3G connectivity, the 2.76 lb. Booklet offers Wi-Fi, GPS, a 120-GB hard-disk drive, 1GB RAM, webcam, and a 16-cell battery that Nokia claims to deliver up to 12 hours of battery life. It uses in Intel Atom 1.6 GHz. processor to run Windows 7 and is made from a single piece of aluminum, much like Apple notebooks. It goes on sale Oct. 22.

At the end of the day, however, this is still a netbook. That means it is likely to feel a tad overwhelmed running more than one application at a time.

There is also the issue of whether customers will use wireless 3G data on a netbook often enough to justify the cost of monthly service. With free or low-cost hotspots abounding and guest networks popping up at businesses and in people's homes, the need for 3G data may not be as large as many users think.

I have been considering a 3G card or mobile hotspot for my own business, based on the occasional need for "right now" Internet access in places away from hotspots. I have yet to justify it, but keep trying to convince myself the need is real--that's $60-a-month real.

When/if I buy, it won't be a netbook with a built-in 3G connection. Too limiting. So no Booklet 3G for me, even if it's tempting.

David Coursey tweets as @techinciter and can be contacted via his Web site.

To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
Shop Tech Products at Amazon