Sprint Netbook Isn't The Deal It May Seem

Sprint is out today with its first netbook, a Dell Inspiron Mini 10-inch model that sells for $199.99, but isn't quite the deal it seems to be.

  • First, customers must sign-up for a two-year 5GB monthly data plan at $59.99-a-month to get the discount.
  • Second, the $199.99 price is after a $100 mail-in rebate, so the up-front cost is $299. Which is what Dell sells the Mini 10 for on its Web site.
  • Third, because the broadband modem is embedded in the netbook, you can't move the service from one computer for another.

Thus, customers end up with a powerful, if pricey, Internet connection permanently tied to an under-powered portable computer. And don't forget to apply for the rebate.

This "deal" is also only available in Minneapolis-St. Paul, according to published reports. You may or may not (if you're lucky) find it on the Sprint site after you enter your local ZIP code.

AT&T and Verizon already offer netbooks, including a Dell in AT&T's case. Sprint's entry seems to be a test-marketing program that may or may not expand based on customer acceptance.

I realize this may be tilting at windmills, but I oppose the bundling of discounted netbooks with wireless broadband contracts. I also oppose handset subsidies. Both practices are bad for consumers. Better to have phones that can move from one carrier to another, as the customer desires.

In this case, a better deal is to take advantage of discounts on carrier-provided broadband card that can move from computer-to-computer or to choose the Mi-Fi portable access point, which can distribute the broadband connection to as many as five Wi-Fi-equipped computers.

David Coursey tweets as @techinciter and can be contacted via his Web site.

To comment on this article and other PCWorld content, visit our Facebook page or our Twitter feed.
  
Shop Tech Products at Amazon