Supply of Critical Rare-earth Elements About to Expand
By Kerry Davis
PCWorldOct 31, 2011 3:13 pm PDT
There are rare-earth elements in your computer, digital camera, television, smartphone, in the batteries of hybrid vehicles, in long-lasting lightbulbs and serving as critical magnets in guided missiles.
Yet the available supply of rare-earth elements has been cut in the past few years. Nearly all the world’s processing facilities are located in China, which started reducing export quotas about two years ago, then restricted exports further following a dispute last year with Japan over an island. China is also closing some of its rare-earth processors, citing environmental concerns.
Together, the actions have increased the costs of rare-earth minerals, which have soared by 1,500 percent on average during the past year, alarming the U.S. government.
Some relief may be coming. Efforts to diversify the supply of rare-earth minerals should get a boost later this year when two mines, one in the U.S. and one in Australia, ramp up production. (Watch a video of the U.S. mine below.)
Supplies aren’t expected to match demand for years, however, triggering a worldwide rush to locate and extract rare-earth elements. (The minerals are known as elements once they are mined.)
“It’s gotten the attention of Congress,” said U.S. Geological Survey researcher Thomas Frost, noting that the USGS’s 2011 budget includes a directive to research rare-earth minerals.
“We’ve realized we need to better understand what potential sources of rare earths there are in the U.S., and in the world, that are not controlled by China, and that hadn’t been considered before,” he said.
The U.S. mine, owned by Molycorp, has reopened after closing in 2002 following radioactive wastewater spills and price competition. The largest spills, from a pipeline to Nevada, occurred in the late 1990s, in protected lands in the Mojave Desert. The company has since changed its ownership structure.
“We want people who buy from us to know we do things the right way,” said Mark Smith, Molycorp CEO, who says Molycorp has a new, environmentally friendly mission. “We care about the environment and we care about what we do, and we think that makes a difference with customers today,” he said.
Molycorp’s facility, in Mountain Pass, California, will expand production dramatically. It’s being rebuilt to produce up to 40,000 metric tons of rare-earth elements by 2013, which would be a 700 percent increase from its production target for the end of this year.
Just off of its own exit on Interstate 15, about an hour’s drive from Las Vegas, the Mountain Pass mining site is nestled in a small valley between two mountain ranges in the desert.
The carbonatite deposit, which contains a variety of ore types, was discovered by prospectors in 1949, according to a U.S. geologist. About 8 percent of the deposit contains rare-earth minerals, a good ratio in rare-earth mining.
Seventeen elements on the periodic table of elements are considered rare earth, including neodymium and terbium. Molycorp mines 10 of the rare-earth elements by hauling ore-laden rocks from the ground, crushing them, and then chemically extracting the elements.
“Molycorp picked it up pretty quickly and really developed the mine,” said Keith Long, a mineral economist and geologist with USGS, who believes Molycorp is a pioneer in the technology to extract rare-earth elements.
Molycorp remained a big player in the global market even as it competed for the lowest price with China, according to Long.
“Starting in the 1980s, China was able to start taking over the rare-earth market, which it was able to do because its mining industry is at a primitive, low-cost model,” he said.
A large, open earth pit that looks like the impression an upside-down pyramid would make sits in the midst of the desert at Mountain Pass. Trucks that can hold up to 75 metric tons of dirt carefully wind past other trucks, hugging the sides of the boxy pit walls.
The pit is about 150 meters deep. The scale makes workers’ trucks, parked near the top of the pit, look like children’s toy cars.
There is a small pool of water in the center of the pit, but the trucks are driven to one of the sides, where earth is pushed into the beds of the trucks, then driven back out. The pit is being expanded and prepared to harvest ore, where a likely looking deposit for heavy concentration of rare-earth minerals has been flagged with a large orange “X.”
Molycorp is in phase one of its reopening, and employees are proud to take reporters around the 2,222-acre facility, where new buildings are going up in all directions. Molycorp is building a combined heat and power plant, a wastewater recycling center, a rock cracking and chemical leeching facility, and a post-processing facility for the waste rock processing and storage facility.
Molycorp is about to have company, which its CEO says is welcome. An Australian rare-earth metals mine owned by Lynas is set to open by the end of 2011, according to information on its website.
There are nine bills before the U.S. Congress now, relating to either finding more rare-earth minerals, protecting rare-earth elements for munitions supplies or recycling electronic components that have rare-earth elements inside them.
And the U.S. Department of Defense released a report last month saying the U.S. is too dependent on Chinese rare-earth minerals.
“It is essential that a stable non-Chinese source of REO [rare-earth oxides] be established so that the U.S. RE supply chain is no longer solely dependent on China’s RE exports,” the report states.
It takes 10 to 15 years for an ore deposit to develop into a rare-earth mining site, due to funding and permitting, which meant China’s export hold put the world supply of rare-earth elements in jeopardy.
“We were fortunate that two projects were in advanced stages when this crisis hit,” Long said.
Still, geologists expect that the demand for rare-earth minerals will exceed the available world supply until at least 2015.