Where is the best place to buy desktop PCs? Here’s what we found.
(See the box of links at right for the other categories we looked at, and for our methodology for choosing the winners and losers in each category.)
The Winners for Desktop PCs
Amazon took first place among the retailers we investigated in the desktop PCs category.
Amazon has the largest array of desktops available anywhere and one of the easiest-to-use Websites.
Though prices were consistent across most of the retailers we looked at, Amazon’s massive selection increases your odds of finding the best possible deal.
Indeed, on some models we checked, prices were $75 to $100 below what you’d pay at the manufacturer’s site.
Still, we recommend shopping around to discover a store’s particular policies. (Click to enlarge the accompanying chart to see how all of the stores in our survey ranked for desktop PCs).
Best Buy’s online store earned the next-best overall rating after Amazon’s. If you like to spend hands-on time with a PC before buying, its in-store experience is your best bet. Its staff ranked among the most helpful of the retailers we investigated. Reps answered our test questions accurately and often made alternative recommendations, based on our family-use scenarios.
The Others
Online-only shops CDW, Newegg, and TigerDirect carried lots of PCs, but navigating the listings was harder than at Amazon, and the systems available were from smaller manufacturers.
The retailer’s phone system directs calls to the Sears Store Support Center, where an operator answers questions about basic product information and pricing.
However, a salesperson in Minneapolis thoroughly answered our questions and recommended a capable (and less expensive) family-friendly PC similar to one on our shopping list.
Staples generally gave solid advice over the phone. Its in-store array of PC models was smallish but adequate; its Website’s selection was far more limited than many competitors’.
RadioShack and Target carry few desktops online and none in their stores. When consulted by phone, Walmart’s sales clerks had to shuffle to and from stockrooms to check on availability; this led to aggravatingly long hold times and (in some instances) less than cordial assistance. Walmart’s Web presence was a bit better organized, but it offered the smallest selection we saw.
Products We Shopped For and the Test Question We Asked
We asked the sales associate the following question about each desktop (and were hoping for the following response):
Q: Which version of Windows 7 is right for me?
A: Windows 7 Home Premium offers media sharing and user account protection suitable for PC buyers who don’t need the business-oriented security and encryption features of the high-end Windows OSs.
Of Related Interest
See “Technology’s Most (and Least) Reliable Brands“–our annual reader survey of reliability and service for tech products, including desktop PCs.
